<p>The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a <a href="https://www.dailywire.com/topic/texas" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Texas</a> law prohibiting social media companies from censoring speech on the basis of political viewpoint.</p>
<p>In a <a href="https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/22417944/document.pdf">decision</a> Friday, a panel of three judges on the Fifth Circuit upheld the Texas law, vacating an injunction from the <a href="https://www.dailywire.com/news/federal-judge-blocks-texas-social-media-censorship-law-abbotts-office-slams-move-as-hostile-to-americas-free-speech-foundation" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Western District of Texas</a>.</p>
<p>In the 90-page ruling, the Fifth Circuit took aim at censorship by social media platforms, debunking the claim that the platforms would have their free speech rights restricted by the law. Instead, the Court found that the law would stop censorship conduct and protect the rights of individual users to speak freely on the platform.</p>
<p>&#8220;A Texas statute named <a href="https://fb.watch/fAUJHHajyg/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">House Bill 20</a> generally prohibits large social media platforms from censoring speech based on the viewpoint of its speaker,&#8221; Fifth Circuit Judge Andrew S. Oldham wrote in the opinion of the court. &#8220;The platforms urge us to hold that the statute is facially unconstitutional and hence cannot be applied to anyone at any time and under any circumstances. In urging such sweeping relief, the platforms offer a rather odd inversion of the First Amendment. That Amendment, of course, protects every person’s right to &#8216;the freedom of speech.&#8217; But the platforms argue that buried somewhere in the person’s enumerated right to free speech lies a corporation’s <em>unenumerated</em> right to <em>muzzle</em> speech.&#8221;</p>
<p>&#8220;Today we reject the idea that corporations have a freewheeling First Amendment right to censor what people say,&#8221; Oldham added.</p>
<p>The court first rejected the social media platforms&#8217; claim that the law is too broad, saying that the law does not chill speech, but chills censorship instead. &#8220;HB 20’s prohibitions on censorship will cultivate rather than stifle the marketplace of ideas that justifies the overbreadth doctrine in the first place,&#8221; Oldham wrote.</p>
<p>Applying Supreme Court precedent, the court further found that the law does not regulate the speech of the platforms at all, neither compelling them to speak nor restricting them from speaking; instead, it protects the speech of users, and regulates platforms&#8217; conduct as it relates to that speech. &#8220;[C]ensorship is at best a form of expressive conduct, for which the overbreadth doctrine provides only &#8216;attenuate[d]&#8217; protection,&#8221; Oldham wrote.</p>
<p>The court cited Section 230, saying that the platforms are not &#8220;speaking&#8221; when they host other people&#8217;s speech. The court also rejected the platforms&#8217; claims of &#8220;editorial discretion&#8221; on two bases: first, the court noted that unlike newspapers, social media platforms do not claim responsibility for the content they host, and are in fact protected from such liability by Section 230. Second, newspapers engage in content moderation <em>before</em> it it published; platforms, on the other hand, engage in censorship <em>after</em> users publish their content. Furthermore, the Fifth Circuit cited the common carrier doctrine, which empowers Texas to prevent the platforms from discriminating against users who live in Texas.</p>
<p>&#8220;We reject the Platforms’ attempt to extract a freewheeling censorship right from the Constitution’s free speech guarantee,&#8221; the Fifth Circuit concluded. &#8220;The Platforms are not newspapers. Their censorship is not speech. They’re not entitled to pre-enforcement facial relief. And HB 20 is constitutional because it neither compels nor obstructs the Platforms’ own speech in any way.&#8221;</p>
<p>The court vacated the district court&#8217;s injunction on the law, and remanded it back to the Western District of Texas for further proceedings in light of the opinion.</p>

<script async src="https://www.instagram.com/embed.js"></script>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
<script async src="https://www.tiktok.com/embed.js"></script><div data-widget-host="revcontent" data-pub-id="165152" data-widget-id="290588"></div><script src="https://delivery.revcontent.com/165152/290588/widget.js"></script>

Fifth Circuit Deals Huge Legal Blow To Social Media Censorship, Upholds Texas Law Banning It

CONTINUE READING

Comer Says He ‘Can’t Track Down The Informant’ In Biden Family Investigation

Autistic Grocery Clerk Fired From California Supermarket After He Was Violently Assaulted Three Separate Times: Report

Justice Is…Bovine? Herd Of Cows Helps Round Up Criminal In North Carolina

Gavin Newsom’s Revised Budget Will Make California’s Budget Deficit Worse, Even As State Mulls Enormous Reparations Package

Oklahoma Police Run Toward To Cries For ‘Help’, Coming From A Very Upset Goat

California’s Reparations Committee Wants State To Apologize For Ronald Reagan Coining ‘Welfare Queens.’ Except, He Didn’t.

News

Censorship

Court

Section 230 Social Media Censorship

Texas

A video goes viral showing a baby being refused his mother by two gay "dads". This is just the tip of the iceberg, which is why we will have an important discussion today about surrogacy. 

Hour 1

The Matt Walsh Show

Ep. 1765 - This Video Is One Of The Worst Things I've Seen In A Long Time 

The Strait of Hormuz officially opens for business (kind of), the Pope makes “shocking” comments on immigration, and President Trump promises UFO disclosure at TPUSA. 


The Michael Knowles Show

Ep. 1956 -  Pope Leo's "SHOCKING" Immigration Comments EXPLAINED

A false miscreed has corrupted our leadership class.


The Andrew Klavan Show

Ep. 1275 - Dumb, Dumber and Progressive

President Trump announces a 10-day ceasefire between Lebanon and Israel, a murder-suicide involving former Democratic Lieutenant Governor Justin Fairfax shakes Virginia, and France and Britain hold a conference to secure the Strait of Hormuz – after the Iranian conflict ends. Get the facts first with Morning Wire.

- - -

Ep. 2738

- - -

Wake up with new Morning Wire merch: https://bit.ly/4lIubt3

- - -

Today's Sponsors:

Alliance Defending Freedom - Visit https://JoinADF.com/WIRE or text 'WIRE' to 83848 to learn more.

Pocket Hose - Text MORNING to 64000 to get a FREE pocket pivot and their 10-pattern sprayer with the purchase of ANY size Copper Head hose. Message and data rates may apply.

Morning Wire

U.S. Expands Hormuz Blockade & VA Fairfax Deaths Investigated | 4.17.26

U.S. Expands Hormuz Blockade & VA Fairfax Deaths Investigated | 4.17.26 [Member Exclusive]

A ceasefire goes into effect between Israel and Lebanon, a tragic murder-suicide rocks Virginia, and Dairy Queen deploys AI in the drive-thru. Get the facts first with Evening Wire.
- - -
Ep. 2737
- - -
Wake up with new Morning Wire merch: https://bit.ly/4lIubt3 
- - -
Today’s Sponsor:

Alliance Defending Freedom - Visit https://JoinADF.com/WIRE or text “WIRE” to 83848 to learn more.


Evening Wire: Lebanon Ceasefire Begins & Murder-Suicide Rocks VA | 4.16.26

The Pendragon Cycle

Menu

— News —

Fifth Circuit Deals Huge Legal Blow To Social Media Censorship, Upholds Texas Law Banning It