Who Was St. Valentine? Separating The Man From The Myth.
To My Valentine Postcard with Two Cupids
K.J. Historical/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images

A version of this article was published in February 2020.

Like St. Patrick’s Day or Mardi Gras, 21st-century society has largely forgotten the religious origins of St. Valentine’s Day. While some may blame that on the overabundance of shameless commercialism, that’s only half the story. Truth be told, we know little about the revered Saint from whom we derive today’s festivities — a man whose ethos rivals that of St. Nicholas.

Who exactly was this St. Valentine? How did he become synonymous with romantic love? Is there, in fact, a man behind the myth?

Though historians have dismissed much of what’s been said of St. Valentine as little more than embellished hagiography, we do know some undisputed facts about the man, namely, that he existed under the reign of Emperor Claudius II and was martyred for practicing the faith around the year 269 AD. In fact, so little historical evidence exists on the details of Valentine’s life that historians now debate whether his legends pertain to two different Saints or one St. Valentine, who would have then called by his Latin name, “Valentinus.”

So unreliable are the accounts of St. Valentine that, in 1969, the Catholic Church removed his name from the General Roman Calendar, opting to leave his liturgical celebration to local calendars. Nevertheless, archeologists and historians do agree that the man existed. His bones can even be visited at Whitefriar Street Church in Dublin; the Catholic Church still considers him a Saint

All that aside, the most popular interpretation of St. Valentine’s life, given the time and culture in which he existed, is quite topical. Though typically associated with courtly, romantic love, St. Valentine could almost be considered a defender of biblical marriage in a time of sexual confusion. Father Frank O’Gara of Whitefriars Street Church described him as a priest who gave his life in defense of holy matrimony.

“He was a Roman Priest at a time when there was an emperor called Claudius who persecuted the church at that particular time,” Father O’Gara explained to CBN. “He also had an edict that prohibited the marriage of young people. This was based on the hypothesis that unmarried soldiers fought better than married soldiers because married soldiers might be afraid of what might happen to them or their wives or families if they died.”

“I think we must bear in mind that it was a very permissive society in which Valentine lived,” continued Father O’Gara. “Polygamy would have been much more popular than just one woman and one man living together. And yet some of them seemed to be attracted to the Christian faith. But obviously, the church thought that marriage was very sacred between one man and one woman for their life and that it was to be encouraged. And so it immediately presented the problem to the Christian church of what to do about this.”

“The idea of encouraging them to marry within the Christian church was what Valentine was about. And he secretly married them because of the edict,” he added.

When Emperor Claudius caught Valentine violating the edict, legend says that the saint was imprisoned and tortured as punishment. Some legends have been attributed to him during his time in prison, according to Father O’Gara.

“One of the men who was to judge him in line with the Roman law at the time was a man called Asterius, whose daughter was blind,” said the priest. “He was supposed to have prayed with and healed the young girl with such astonishing effect that Asterius himself became Christian as a result.”

St. Valentine suffered a violent martyrdom in the year 269 A.D. when he was allegedly sentenced to a three-part execution by way of beating, stoning, and decapitation. Legend has it that his last words were in a note to Asterius’ daughter – “From your Valentine.”

Whether or not such stories about St. Valentine are indeed true or just embellished hagiography is beside the point, according to Father O’Gara, because St. Valentine symbolizes a principle that all Christians should live by. “What Valentine means to me as a priest is that there comes a time where you have to lay your life upon the line for what you believe,” he exclaimed. “And with the power of the Holy Spirit, we can do that — even to the point of death.”

Though February 14 is St. Valentine’s feast day, the holiday known as “Valentine’s Day” and its celebration of courtly, romantic love actually comes from Geoffrey Chaucer’s poem “Parlement of Foules,” which associated the day with the pairing of birds in mid-February.

Love is in the air, indeed.

The Daily Wire is one of America’s fastest-growing conservative media companies and counter-cultural outlets for news, opinion, and entertainment. Get inside access to The Daily Wire by becoming a member.