News

Schools Team Up With Radical Mayor To Block Girls Sports Protection Passed By Voters

The measure won by 13 points, and now opponents want a judge to block it before it takes effect.

Hank Berrien
Listen
Listen
3 min
Schools Team Up With Radical Mayor To Block Girls Sports Protection Passed By Voters
FatCamera/GetyImages

Seattle Public Schools and leftist Mayor Katie Wilson are siding with activists racing to court to freeze Washington’s new ban on trans-identifying boys competing in girls’ school sports, just weeks after voters passed it by a wide margin.

On Wednesday, a coalition of groups including the Washington Education Association and the ACLU of Washington asked a judge to put Initiative 638 on hold before it takes effect December 3. The same night, the Seattle school district filed a brief backing the request. Wilson has thrown her support behind the school board’s push to fight the law in court.

The measure passed easily in the November 3 midterms with about 56% of the vote. It won in 36 of the state’s 39 counties.

Under the law, male students are banned from playing on K-12 girls’ teams. Every girl who wants to play girls’ sports must also have a health care provider verify her sex during her routine sports physical.

Opponents call that a privacy nightmare. Their lawsuit argues the check is unfair because only girls have to go through it, not boys, and that the law violates equal protection and privacy rights. Critics also claim that the checks could end up “outing” kids against their will.

The Seattle district isn’t suing, but it says it can’t make the rules work in the middle of the winter season. About 1,400 of the roughly 2,000 girls on its winter rosters already have valid physicals that don’t include the new verification. Officials say they don’t know whether those athletes can keep playing or will have to be benched, which could leave some teams short of players.

The district also says it doesn’t know how to collect and store the medical paperwork or who should be allowed to see it. It says the initiative conflicts with existing state nondiscrimination protections. It’s worried about legal liability if a court later strikes the law down.

The school board didn’t wait long to fight back. It voted unanimously on November 9 to authorize legal action, less than a week after the election. It had already voted in September to oppose the measure.

The initiative’s backers aren’t buying the district’s complaints. Let’s Go Washington, the group that put the measure on the ballot, says schools have checked athletes’ eligibility for decades. Executive director Darren Littell brushed off the timing concerns, saying, “I do think that it can get done in two weeks.”

Supporters also have the Supreme Court on their side. In June, the justices ruled 6–3 that Idaho’s and West Virginia’s bans on transgender athletes in girls’ and women’s sports were constitutional.

Now the fight goes to a Washington courtroom. A judge is scheduled to hear the request on December 3, the same day the law is supposed to take effect.

Until then, families across the state don’t know if their daughters will be cleared to play.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip