News

Republican Primary Voters In Key Early States Aren’t Buying The Anti-Israel Pitch

"There is no place for antisemitism in the Republican Party."

Virginia Kruta
Listen
Listen
4 min
Republican Primary Voters In Key Early States Aren’t Buying The Anti-Israel Pitch
Chris Unger/Zuffa LLC

While much punditry is made about the shift of young right-wingers against Israel, new polling of early primary states shows that the message still doesn’t resonate across the party writ large.

According to a new poll from OnMessage Inc. for the Combat Antisemitism Movement, Republican voters in Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, and South Carolina have a favorable view of Israel — and see the anti-Israel commentary from figures like Nick Fuentes, Tucker Carlson, and Candace Owens as detrimental to the party as a whole.

The survey found that 68% of likely Republican voters in those states had a favorable view of Israel, while only 17% had an unfavorable view — numbers that align with similar data compiled by Gallup. Additionally, 78% said that the party’s support of Israel made them more likely to vote GOP, or had no impact at all.

When asked about the antisemitic podcast class of the right — such as Carlson, Fuentes, and Owens — the numbers quickly inverted. More than half (53%) said that they had an unfavorable view of Carlson and only 30% approved of him. The numbers were dead even among voters under 45, however, with 46% approving and 46% disapproving.

Owens had a 49% disapproval rating — and only 23% approved of her. Only 25% disapproved of Fuentes — and 13% approved — in part because Fuentes was the least known of the three.

In the same survey, Vice President JD Vance (80% favorable) polled slightly better than President Donald Trump (75% favorable) — and 59% said they agreed with Vance’s stated position regarding Israel: “Israel has a right to exist, and America should remain its ally, however criticism of its government is legitimate, but when it turns into antisemitism that is unacceptable.”

One complicating factor may be Carlson’s connections to Vance — the two have been friends for some time — because the survey also indicated that nearly half (46%) would be less likely to vote for a candidate who was endorsed by Carlson. Only 16% said a Carlson endorsement would make them more likely to vote for a candidate.

An overwhelming majority (83%) also said that they had a lower opinion of Carlson after he praised Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) and bashed his Republican opponent Mike Rogers just before the election.

Axios reached out to Fuentes, Owens, and Carlson for comment — and got no response from either Fuentes or Owens. Carlson replied via text, suggesting that the poll was inaccurate because it was funded by Zionists.

“The poll was commissioned by the ‘Combat Antisemitism Movement’? Seriously? Pretty funny. Where does their funding come from?” he asked. “If the point is to convince Republican candidates that American voters love Netanyahu and want more wars for Israel, good luck in the next election,” he said. “It’s so absurd. But I’m sure you’ll have Republican senators waving around the poll results like they mean something.”

Former Virginia Republican Attorney General Jason Miyares, who serves as a U.S. Advisory Board Member of the Combat Antisemitism Movement, pushed back.

“For a Republican presidential candidate, standing up against antisemitism is not a political risk — it is the price of admission and good politics. Most importantly, it is simply the right thing to do,” he said.

The survey collected answers from 250 likely voters in each of the four states — 1,000 in total — and was “stratified to reflect historical turnout.” It was conducted between November 7 and November 10, and has a margin of error of 3.1%.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip