New Jersey’s Proposed Islamophobia Laws Are Blasphemy Laws By Another Name
Credit: Getty Images

DW Opinion

New Jersey’s Proposed Islamophobia Laws Are Blasphemy Laws By Another Name

Don’t let New Jersey import Europe’s speech police.

Brad Schaeffer
Listen
Listen
8 min

The First Amendment contains no exception for Islam. Yet New Jersey’s Assembly Bill A1146, sponsored by Assemblyman Joe Danielsen (D-17), would dangerously move our state toward establishing one. By adopting an official definition of “Islamophobia” for use in civil and criminal discrimination matters, legislators are proposing something profoundly alien to the American tradition: government involvement in determining which criticisms of a religion are permissible and which constitute unacceptable hostility.

This is not merely a hypothetical concern. We need only look across the Atlantic to see where such thinking can lead.

Britain has spent years struggling with the consequences of treating offensive speech as a matter for police attention. Under its notorious non-crime hate incident system, authorities recorded complaints about statements that violated no law whatsoever. In 2021, Britain’s Court of Appeal found that police guidance governing the practice disproportionately interfered with freedom of expression. By March 2026, the government announced plans to replace the system.

The country that gave us John Locke and John Stuart Mill found itself policing perfectly legal opinions simply because someone deemed them “hateful” — a thoroughly subjective judgment that can all too easily be weaponized against political or ideological opponents. Like so many once-powerful words, from “racism” to “fascism,” the term “hate” has been so casually and indiscriminately deployed in the modern progressive lexicon that it has lost any meaning. Worse, a word whose definition increasingly depends on who is speaking, who is offended, and who holds power is hardly a sound standard upon which to base the application of criminal law.

No matter. New Jersey apparently wants to experiment with its own version of officially defined religious offense.

The problem is particularly acute when the religion in question is Islam. Unlike the American Judeo-Christian constitutional tradition, classical Islamic jurisprudence includes prohibitions against blasphemy and, in some interpretations, apostasy. In several contemporary Muslim-majority countries, blasphemy remains a criminal offense, sometimes punishable by death.

These are not obscure theological differences. They represent fundamentally competing ideas about the relationship between religious authority, individual liberty, and the state. America settled this in 1791: our Bill of Rights protects religious beliefs, but it does not shield religious doctrines from criticism.

Democratic assemblyman Danielsen’s proposed legislation muddies that distinction. Its definition includes vague categories such as “severe disparagement” of Muslim culture and allegations involving Muslim political influence or demographic change. But who determines what constitutes severe disparagement? Would criticism of Islamic teachings on women, homosexuality, apostasy, or religious minorities qualify? Would recounting historically accurate narratives of the Prophet Muhammad’s bloodthirsty and lascivious behavior land one in the slammer? How much time would one serve for burning a Quran? Would merely questioning the political ambitions of Islamist organizations — and their Trojan Horse lawmakers — become evidence of discriminatory intent?

These are legitimate subjects of public debate. And they must remain so, regardless of how offensive someone finds the discussion. Growing up, we were taught the famous proclamation by Evelyn Beatrice Hall, once a cornerstone of bona fide liberal thought: “I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it.” That goes for critique of Islam too. That’s the way a free society rolls.

The bill’s defenders will point to language — which reads almost as an afterthought — affirming First Amendment protections. But that assurance becomes considerably less reassuring when the same legislation instructs law enforcement and public officials to consider its expansive definition when determining discriminatory intent.

The danger is not just that criticism of Islam suddenly becomes a crime, although criminalizing disparaging words is grotesque enough in any free society. It is that ordinary citizens will increasingly hesitate to engage in legitimate criticism because they fear official scrutiny, reputational damage, or legal entanglement. That chilling effect is precisely what free-speech protections are designed to prevent. (And what Islamists seek.)

We should dispense with the intellectual sleight of hand that equates criticism of Islam with hatred of Muslims. (Although hating a certain group is not a crime, regardless of how unseemly it is. White men face such animosity every day.) Islam is a religion, a collection of doctrines and historical claims subject to the same scrutiny as Christianity, Judaism, or any other belief system. Islamism, meanwhile, is a political ideology whose relationship with terror organizations as well as its antipathy towards Western liberal values, without which our nation would cease to exist as we know it, deserves particularly vigorous examination.

Neither is a race. Neither is beyond criticism.

No one should suffer violence, threats, or unlawful discrimination because of his or her faith. Existing law already prohibits such conduct. But protecting individuals from genuine persecution is not remotely the same thing as shielding their religion from criticism, and certainly not to the point where it becomes a crime to do so.

I’m a Catholic. If you think Pope Leo is wrong, say so. If you think the Vatican is a disgrace, have at it. I may argue with you. I may even get a little hot under the collar. Somehow, I’ll get through the day without asking the State of New Jersey to weigh in on how severely you’ve disparaged me. Indeed, as the late, great Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia might have reminded us, “the Constitution is not a guarantee to not be offended.” Or as another great philosopher Denis Leary once said: “Life sucks. Wear a helmet.”

The question is simple: Will New Jersey, one of the most prominent states in the American Revolution, uphold the American principle that no religion is above scrutiny, or begin the same process that is propelling Europe towards civic and cultural upheaval by accommodating the very notion of religious offense that the First Amendment was designed to keep beyond government’s reach?

Someone practicing his religion without imposing it on others has every right to worship in peace. Someone who threatens that family or vandalizes its places of worship should answer under the law. The rest of us, however, have every right to critique and argue about what is preached inside. That includes the fellow who opposes the tenets of Islam with all the grace of a drunk at closing time.

Freedom is messy. Trenton can live with the mess. That American lawmakers are now considering going down the same road as the nations we see being torn asunder due to an influx of Islamic immigrants who demand their host country accommodate their cultures, beliefs, and practices, as opposed to the other way around, shows just how deep into the foundation of the Democratic Party the termites of Islamism, Bolshevism, and unconstitutional leftism have burrowed.

Some ideas are best left to die where they were conceived. Americans rejected blasphemy laws for a reason. We should not resurrect them under a more fashionable, more politically expedient name.

 ***

Brad Schaeffer is a commodities fund manager, author, and columnist whose articles have appeared on the pages of The Wall Street Journal, NY Post, NY Daily News, The Daily Wire, National Review, The Hill, The Federalist, Washington Examiner, TheBlaze, Zerohedge, and other outlets. He is the author of three books. His latest book, “A War For Half The World: Why the Real Battle for the Future was Fought in the Pacific,” will be released in February 2027 and is available now for preorder.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip