How To Serve Up Real Conservatism At Thanksgiving Dinner
Credit: Getty Images

DW Opinion

How To Serve Up Real Conservatism At Thanksgiving Dinner

Young people – what does it mean to actually be conservative?

Chloe Trapanotto
Listen
Listen
7 min

Judging by online chatter, entertainment culture, and recent Republican blunders, one could easily come away with the notion that conservatism is out of style. 

Commentators call us bigoted idiots. Celebrities treat us like the final obstacle between them and some Hunger Games revolution. Democrats win seats promising free healthcare, housing, childcare, and gas, wrapped with a red bow. From their socialist, spellbinding soapbox they declare love is love (even if that means loving men in women’s bathrooms), every desire is a human right (even when it requires stealing from someone else), and our open borders should look like open arms. Men bad. Christianity bad. Billionaires bad. Oil bad. Monogamy bad. Capitalism bad. And conservatives are just the weirdos crapping in the Cheerios of progress.

The Left is easy to diagnose. They’re a party of omnicauses: identity and envy, climate and cancellation. They stand for nothing and everything at once. Conservatives stand for something older and clearer. So why is it so hard to voice and defend it? Partly, because we keep mixing up the philosophy with the party.

Conservatism and the Republican Party are not the same thing. The GOP is a vehicle that wins elections, while conservatism is a set of ideas about how free people flourish. Donald Trump, our Republican leader, is a populist who runs on political instinct rather than strict principles. 

And while that can be useful, it isn’t our philosophy. That’s why conservatives have felt disjointed.

So what is conservatism? Well, the philosophy took shape in the 1700s. In France, the Jacobins (radical leftists) called for “liberty and equality,” which quickly morphed into terror, mass beheadings, the destruction of churches and traditions, and the toppling of any “oppressive” institution they felt needed to go. A man named Edmund Burke watched this, and wrote that radical attempts to redesign society from pure, stupid theory produced chaos, never justice. Instead, societies are the slow, gradual product of good habits, nuclear families, strong laws, and inherited wisdom.

At the same time, Americans were drafting the Federalist Papers. Hamilton, Madison, and Jay argued for a Constitution that limited the power of the federal (national) government, separated it into competing branches, protected hard-earned property and God-given individual rights, and left the rest to states and locals. Why? Because concentrated power is dangerous. As Madison wrote in Federalist No. 51, “If men were angels, no government would be necessary.” Power-hungry hippos don’t become angelic just because they claim to act for “the people.”

More simply, conservatism was born of the observation that liberty needs order, that abstract promises of magical rainbow equality often end in coercion, and that institutions that produce tried-and-true stability and freedom (families, churches, local governments, free markets, rule of law) deserve our defense, not calls to nuke them.

The clearest modern expression of this philosophy came under the great Ronald Reagan, who governed on the simple premise that government exists to protect our rights, not to be their source or to solve every problem under the sun. “The nine most terrifying words in the English language,” he said, “are: I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” He signed one of the largest tax cuts in American history, cut regulation, rebuilt the military, and treated Soviet communism as something wicked that must be defeated. Under this conservative beacon, Americans saw recovery from stagflation, millions of new jobs, falling inflation, and body blows to the Soviet Union that restored America’s global leadership.

He did it all while spending roughly a year of his presidency on horseback at his California ranch. Maybe we just need to mandate that every president get more fresh air?

But the conservatism of that time was straightforward. Keep the federal government small so as to give authority to the states, because America is not one-size-fits-all. Cut taxes and regulations so people can keep and invest what they earn. Maintain a strong national defense, reject communism, and remember that America, though imperfect, is good.

True conservatives still want that. Voices like Marco Rubio still want that. We want ordered liberty under law, not anarchy and not micromanagement. We want individual responsibility and free markets, because incentives work: when you reward production, risk-taking, and intact families, you get more of them; when you subsidize dependency and punish success to fund “free” everything, you get fewer jobs and fathers, and nonexistent growth. We want strong families because children need mom and dad more than they need Uncle Sam. We want secure borders and the rule of law because a country that can’t control who comes in cannot maintain the conditions that made it worth entering. We want a moral order based in reality because biology isn’t optional, trade-offs always exist, and there will be winners, and there will be losers. Such is life. Dignity comes from hard work, failing, and trying again. 

But conservatives must understand this: conservatism collapses without a moral and spiritual bedrock.

John Adams said our Constitution was made for a moral and religious people and is inadequate for any other. John Jay wrote that a free society relies on Christian morality. Reagan made it clear that self-government required a people capable of governing themselves, which requires moral formation. Nowhere in their wisdom was there room for godless grandstanding, a culture of envy and grievance, or the notion that truth is customizable.

It feels difficult to be a loud and proud, out-of-the-closet conservative today because the alternative sells faster. Just as sex sells, so does free stuff. It’s wrong, but “free stuff, no trade-offs, you’re the victim, disagree, and you’re evil” feels nice and easy to some people in the moment. Conservatism asks for maturity: facing facts, even when they offend our amygdalas, and improving what already works instead of burning it down. We need our politicians to act like strict parents and say no. Not just to us, but to themselves.

Conservatism isn’t complicated. We’re just conserving what we know works. Limited government. Free enterprise. Strong families. Secure borders. Moral order grounded in reality. When put into practice, it’s the truest form of progress.

Make sure to loudly and proudly remind your family of that at this year’s Thanksgiving dinner. Go forth, Patriot, make conservatism stylish again.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip