How Democrats Used Dark-Money Influencers To Win The 2026 Messaging War
Credit: Al Drago/Getty Images

DW Opinion

How Democrats Used Dark-Money Influencers To Win The 2026 Messaging War

How do you win a war when you have everything to lose?

Chloe Trapanotto
Listen
Listen
9 min

The Midterms of 2026 didn’t come down to fact over fiction, didn’t redound to truth over tale, didn’t even amount to quality candidate versus quack. Instead, the party that won the messaging war won.

And Democrats just admitted to using startling social media guerrilla tactics that won them battles Republicans have a hard time even joining.

Van Jones, the CNN commentator and delator in our story, admitted just days after the blunami that he could finally reveal how his party hoodwinked voters into regurgitating the red pill and gulping down the blue.

Don’t get mad at me, I was given permission to reveal this. How did we win the narrative on affordability? Was it just these nice little Democrats out there running for office…? No. The Republicans never figured out what we were doing. There’s something called the American Accountability Network, tens of thousands of online humans, not bots, coordinated to make the affordability message a winning message online. 32.5 million people hit on Instagram every day. 88.8 million hit on Twitter, X, every single day. And 185 million Facebook hits every single day. And they never figured it out. The Republicans could not understand it wasn’t bots. It was actual human beings.

What he fails to mention is this: if Republican pundits and politicians couldn’t spot these coordinated, CIA-style tactics for reshaping voters’ perception of the economy, the voters certainly couldn’t. They were bamboozled.

He goes on to say these influencers were “driving the kitchen table affordability message and tying that to Democrats on a positive and Republicans on a negative… They couldn’t get any traction on these cultural war issues anymore because we figured out how to get around all that.”

This is an astonishing admission. Democrats knew they couldn’t win on a single cultural issue (trans, border, crime), so they flooded the public square with pessimistic propaganda. “Why does everything feel so unaffordable?” “Gas is higher than it has ever been.” This sentiment was soaked into every algorithm.

But influencers rarely post on behalf of other organizations for free. There is no way the American Accountability Network didn’t offer compensation for their human robots’ good little work. And its funding? Undisclosed. 

Millions of voters were nudged daily, by influencers likely paid by who-the-heck-knows, to believe the worst.

I’ll admit that inflation is still higher than it was in 2019, though it’s a third of what it was under Joe Biden. With tariffs and the Strait of Hormuz being under fire, grocery and gas prices are still too high.

But as Curt Anderson told my editor Ben Domenech in his latest Punch interview, in the weeks before the election, Americans had a lower opinion of the economy and lower expectations for growth than they did in the midst of the financial crisis, according to Gallup.

That’s insanity. 

Between 2007 and 2009, hundreds of millions of families lost their homes while the government spent billions bailing out companies, a move that generations of American children will be paying off in taxes.

2008 and 2026? We are not the same. 

But the Left made you think the present is worse, and it was easy for them, thanks to an unfortunate truth of the online world: left-leaning and apolitical influencers can be paid to post whatever they’re handed. If a cheeky, pop-culture TikToker complains about gas prices and blames the evil, racist Republicans, her followers applaud. If a makeup guru posts about affordability, she’s pampered with more PR packages. If a mom-fluencer takes to her livestream to lament the cost of childcare or healthcare and begs the Democrats to fix it, the low-propensity voter takes away exactly one thing, after leaving a heart emoji: #FDJT.

But if a secretly right-wing creator opens up about her politics, or worse, her love for Jesus Christ, she is blacklisted, unfollowed, shunned, and scorned.

How do we win a messaging war when our messengers have everything to lose?

How do we win a broader war against evil when, before sharing a faith-based message, creators feel the need to vocally brace for backlash?

“I’ll lose followers for saying this… but…” 

I’m in a unique spot. I branded my content as “Catholic. Conservative. Commonsensical” from the get-go, and I’m not shy about my beliefs. It’s freeing and isolating in equal measure. Others aren’t so lucky, or so unlucky, depending on how you look at it. Plenty of conservative, Christian, Mormon, Jewish, and moderate influencers are rewarded with brand deals, income, and swelling follower counts for keeping quiet. The price is their right to speak freely and to use their platforms to sway voters, not just viewers.

In our current culture, it’s easy for the Left to pay creators to push its message. They have nothing to fear. The Right? A handful of us will speak up about the issues shaping our nation’s future, and we’ll do it for free. But you couldn’t pay most online Republicans to come out of the closet about their conservatism.

To topple this Goliath, the GOP needs to run on infallible messaging, one that echoes through the voices brave enough to carry it, and loudly and strategically remind voters that Democrats have no plan to back up their hollow slogans.

Everything to lose is exactly why we can’t afford to stay quiet. 

Republicans are still the party of anti-socialism and meritocracy, of American greatness, faith, family, and freedom. We have the policies to win this war and win this country back. We just need to be loud enough to cut through the noise, gaslighting, and influencer harvesting. Americans crave authenticity, sincerity, and honesty. Let’s give it to them.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip