News

El-Sayed’s Plan For Israel: Have You Tried Not Being So Jewish?

"That's, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination."

Virginia Kruta
Listen
Listen
3 min

Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) laid out what he believed Israel should be, and his basic assessment was that the world’s only Jewish State should be less Jewish.

El-Sayed, who has sparked criticism throughout his campaign by associating with radical antisemitic and pro-communist streamer Hasan Piker, discussed the topic with The Atlantic’s Jonathan Lemire and argued that he’d be less critical of Israel if it were less centered on one specific religion.

“What should Israel be?” Lemire asked.

“I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, equal rights for all its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws. That’s, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination,” El Sayed replied, apparently suggesting that his problem was not with Israel’s existence as a whole but with its designation as a Jewish state.

“And let’s step back from here, because we always start from the premise of what is Israel now and what should it be versus the premise of what should be the juxtaposition of states — or state — that upholds equal rights for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike,” El-Sayed continued, never addressing the fact that Arabs and Muslims already do live freely in Israel.

El-Sayed raised eyebrows weeks earlier when he stated definitively that a Palestinian state had a right to exist but suggested that Israel’s right to exist ought to be conditional.

During a “60 Minutes” interview with Ross Douthat, El-Sayed’s answer was an immediate yes when he was asked whether a Palestinian state had a right to exist. Douthat followed by asking whether Israel also had a right to exist.

“Yes, if there is a shared understanding,” El-Sayed answered.

“Wait, you said —” Douthat pushed back.

“Let me just, let me just … I believe, and this is the problem with this debate, we start from where we sit rather than start from principles. … If the Palestinian people decide — and the Israeli people decide — that they want two states for two people, and they decide that on equal terms, I’m for it. If they decide that they want one state shared in a different way, I’m for that,” El-Sayed explained.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip