News

Democrat Mary Peltola Flips Alaska Senate Seat After Dirty Dem ‘Decoy Dan’ Scheme

The race narrowly avoided going into ranked-choice tabulation after Peltola broke 50% of the vote by just 353 votes.

Leif Le Mahieu
Listen
Listen
6 min
Democrat Mary Peltola Flips Alaska Senate Seat After Dirty Dem ‘Decoy Dan’ Scheme
Credit: Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images.

Democrat Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Alaska Senator Dan Sullivan in yet another blow to Republicans.

Peltola defeated Sullivan 50.1% to 45.8% with over 99% of the vote counted. Sullivan’s seat was one of those heavily targeted by Democrats in their quest to take back control of the Senate. Democrats took back the Senate on Election Day and will take power in January with a 56-44 majority.  

The race narrowly avoided going into ranked-choice tabulation after Peltola broke 50% of the vote by just 353 votes. Peltola defeated Sullivan by 12,458 votes in race that stretched on for two weeks and saw 287,896 ballots counted. A second Dan Sullivan, reportedly recruited by Democrat operatives to confuse voters, won 4,760 votes and another candidate recruited by out-of-state operatives named Gerald Heikes got 6,105 votes.

The race was the most expensive Senate campaign in state history as both parties dumped tens of millions of dollars into the race. Peltola will be the first Democrat to represent the state in the Senate since 2014 when Sullivan ousted incumbent Democrat Senator Mark Begich. 

The race dragged on for days after Peltola led Sullivan by just 626 votes at the end of Election Day with both candidates under 50%.

The incumbent Sullivan released a memo after Election Day arguing that both the outstanding ballots left to be counted and the ranked-choice system would have led to him being re-elected. He expected most of the early voting yet to be counted to break his way.

Both candidates also got involved in a legal battle over the handling of absentee ballots. Peltola sued the state to obtain records of rejected absentee ballots while Sullivan intervened to block that effort.

“It should surprise no one that the same D.C. lawyers who spent more than a year conspiring with Mary Peltola’s campaign to deceive Alaskan voters are now asking a court to let her campaign ignore Alaska law and change the rules while votes are still being counted,” Sullivan’s campaign said. 

The next major shift in the race came on November 10 as Peltola extended her lead to 2,517 votes and the vote total for the second Sullivan bumped to 3,651 votes.

On the campaign trail, Peltola branded herself as a moderate. She claimed to oppose gender-confused boys participating in girls’ sports and bans on AR-15s while vowing to support border security and the oil and gas industry. 

That image contrasted with her record in Congress as she voted against the “Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act of 2023” — legislation prohibiting school athletic programs from allowing boys who identify as girls to play in girls’ sports.

The victory is another example of Democrats capitalizing on Alaska’s quirky ranked-choice voting system and voters’ streak of independence. 

The focal point of the race centered on the controversy around the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan, dubbed “Decoy Dan” by Republicans. The second Sullivan was a retired teacher who claimed to be a “pragmatic Republican centrist” upset with President Donald Trump.

A New York Times investigation published last week found that Democrat operatives worked to recruit Sullivan in an apparent effort to undercut the incumbent Republican and confuse voters. 

The effort reportedly involved Peltola campaign staff, Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) officials, political consultants, and an operative who traveled around Alaska under a false name to recruit potential candidates. The scheme worked and “Decoy Dan” appeared on the ballot. 

Peltola’s campaign denied participation in the plot. 

After the polls closed, Trump argued on Truth Social that the second Sullivan ran “solely for the purpose of fraud and confusion” and argued that all of his votes should go to the incumbent Republican.

Before the Times revealed the extent of Democrat meddling in the race, the Justice Department asked a federal court to be prepared to delay certification of the election if the inclusion of the second Dan Sullivan confused voters and cost the incumbent the victory. The delay would allow for an investigation into whether voters were thrown off by the appearance of two Dan Sullivans on the ballot. 

Peltola’s campaign was also dogged by headlines about her treatment of staff and leaked messages showing her wishing that a Planned Parenthood employee would die from a botched abortion. 

Leaked messages show Peltola once texted during her campaign for re-election to the House in 2024 that, “I hope Planned Parenthood knows that if we don’t win it’s more their loss than ours. F*CK THOSE B*TCHES.” 

In another message, she wrote of one Planned Parenthood employee, “I hope she dies of a botched abortion.”

Peltola’s victory comes despite efforts from President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance to hold the seat for Republicans. Trump and Vance made stops in Alaska to shore up support for Sullivan ahead of the election. 

Trump won the state by 13 points during the 2024 presidential election, but many voters in the state identify as “nonpartisan” or “undeclared.” 

Democrats have performed well in some statewide elections in recent years, in large part due to the ranked-choice voting system. Peltola won Alaska’s lone House seat in 2022 after the Republican candidate failed to win a majority and the count went to multiple rounds.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip