News

Blue City Moves To Toss Lawsuit Over Horrific Stabbing Of Iryna Zarutska

Charlotte says it can’t be blamed for the Ukrainian refugee’s stabbing and wants any payout capped at $1 million.

Hank Berrien
Listen
Listen
4 min
Blue City Moves To Toss Lawsuit Over Horrific Stabbing Of Iryna Zarutska
Peter Zay/Anadolu via Getty Images

The city of Charlotte, North Carolina, is trying to make the wrongful death lawsuit over the horrific light-rail killing of Iryna Zarutska go away for good.

City lawyers asked a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge on Monday to throw out the suit. They argue the city is shielded by governmental immunity and can’t be blamed for the knife attack that ended the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee’s life aboard a Lynx Blue Line train last summer.

The city wants the case dismissed “with prejudice” where possible, which would bar the family from ever refiling it.

The motion came weeks after a four-hour mediation session between Zarutska’s uncle and lawyers for the city and its transit security contractor ended in a stalemate, according to court papers. It is the first time Charlotte has publicly answered the family’s accusations.

Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, filed the suit August 21, one day before the anniversary of her death. He sued as administrator of her estate, naming the city and its contractor, Professional Security Services.

The complaint paints a damning picture. It says no guard was on the train when she was attacked, and that Brown rode without paying a fare. It also notes that the light rail has no turnstiles or gates.

The family’s lawyer, Lauren Newton, argues that basic fare enforcement or properly staffed security could have saved Zarutska’s life. She also says the city had the money for all of it.

According to the suit, four people died on or near the Blue Line in the months before Zarutska was killed.

A judge will now decide whether to dismiss some, all or none of the claims against the city. If the motion is denied, the case will move forward.

Zarutska was heading home from her shift at a pizzeria on August 22, 2025, when she was knifed in the neck by a career criminal. Surveillance footage of the attack sparked outrage nationwide. Decarlos Brown Jr., a homeless man with a long rap sheet who once told cops he had schizophrenia, is accused of the slaying. He sits in federal custody, and a hearing in his state murder case has been pushed back to May 2027.

In the filing, city attorneys Lori Keeton and Terry L. Wallace called her death tragic and devastating but put the blame squarely on Brown. They denied that Charlotte “ignored passenger safety.”

The lawyers insisted the Charlotte Area Transit System already ran an “extensive security program” before the killing. They said that included armed and unarmed guards and company police.

Governmental immunity is one of 10 defenses the city raised. Its lawyers argue that policing trains and deploying security are core government functions that are protected from lawsuits.

They also invoked the “public duty” doctrine, a legal principle that says local governments generally can’t be sued for failing to protect the public at large from criminals.

The city also argued that the system-wide crime numbers cited by the family don’t prove a deadly attack like this one was foreseeable. It called Brown’s alleged act an “independent, superseding cause” that breaks any chain of blame. City lawyers also pushed back on the claim that CATS is a for-profit business.

If the suit survives, Charlotte wants the judge to cap any payout at $1 million, the limit set by state law.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip