A Look At One Year Of Marxist Mayhem In NYC
Credit: CHARLY TRIBALLEAU/AFP via Getty Images

DW Opinion

A Look At One Year Of Marxist Mayhem In NYC

Mamdani campaigned on policies that would devastate NYC and its citizens. No one should be surprised that they’re doing exactly that.

Chloe Trapanotto
Listen
Listen
8 min

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.

We’re catching starships with chopsticks, and we’re turning the world’s financial capital into a communist trash can.

Zohran Mamdani’s ascension to the New York City mayoralty was bewildering for many reasons. How did a 35-year-old former rapper, who has never owned a home, who was born in Uganda to a professor who seemingly despises America and a mother who makes movies (some for Disney, no less), become the first openly socialist, openly Muslim mayor of New York City? Are New Yorkers that out of touch with reality? Are they that privileged and that progressive, that they would crown a Hizzoner who rails against wardens, white people, wealth creation, and Wall Street? I guess so.

His election back in November of 2025 was terrifying for a number of reasons, but it did serve as a neat scientific experiment: how much harm can one Marx-worshipping mayor do to the concrete jungle’s golden goose, and its geese?

Well, one year after his victory, we can analyze the losses.

Campaign Promise #1: Handicap the NYPD

Shortly after grabbing the keys to Gracie Mansion, Mamdani scrapped former mayor Eric Adams’s plan to hire 5,000 more police officers. He then ditched his own plan to add 580 after backlash from his Democratic Socialists of America comrades. This week he went further, declaring from his socialist soapbox, Stalin-stache and all, that he would disband the Strategic Response Group (SRG), the unit tasked with countering terrorism and policing violent protests. But don’t worry: in its place he’ll deploy a “dialogue team” of 30 unarmed social workers. Surely they’ll stop the next threat with a stern talking-to.

And if, God forbid, some poor, put-upon protester is arrested for attacking an officer or hurling a bomb into a crowd? An activist judge will be waiting to excuse the misbehavior.

Ayatollah Mamdani recently appointed 16 radical judges, including a jurist nicknamed “Judge Let ’Em Go.” Valentina Morales earned the moniker by freeing 83 of the 101 alleged violent felons who faced her court, including an illegal alien who slashed a 43-year-old with charred glass.

Remember, these are the people who cry that Elon Musk should be arrested for being awesome, and cheer when killers walk. It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.

Mamdani has also upheld the city’s sanctuary laws, shielding violent illegal aliens like Reynaldo Hoel Mayna, who slipped across the California border under Joe Biden, found refuge in New York City, and recently followed a 27-year-old woman into a Brooklyn building and raped her.

Every one of these decisions, made by a little man with less wisdom than a grapefruit, has consequences. While other parts of the nation saw felony assaults fall and rapes climb at a slower pace, New Yorkistan saw felony assaults rise and rape cases jump 5.8%.

He campaigned on policies that would devastate the city and the lives of its citizens. Why would anyone be surprised that they’re doing exactly that?

Campaign promise #2: Fast and Free Buses

This was one of the main draws for voters. Free transportation! Not. One year into this nightmare, not a single bus is free. Worse, fares have climbed to three dollars, and the MTA plans another 4% hike next year. Nearly half of bus riders skip the fare anyway. The buses aren’t cleaner, they aren’t safer, and the decent citizens still paying for them are footing the bill for everyone else.

Campaign Promise #3: Rent Freezes 

Freeze the rent for one million stabilized apartments? He did indeed. It’s a cute little method used by the likes of Chávez and Maduro, and it almost always ends in economic collapse and a severe housing shortage. Now every other renter is paying more than ever, with the median asking rent at $3,785 and $5,375 in Manhattan, where listings are down 28% from 2025. When landlords can’t charge enough to cover costs, they stop buying property, and builders stop building. Supply shrinks, demand surges, and prices skyrocket.

His other assault on landlords comes in the form of a new tenant crisis line. Having trouble paying rent? Dial 311 to be connected with a specialist who can help you dodge your responsibilities! Have a minor problem in your building? Mamdani’s minions will help you sue your landlord and win, so that the government can take ownership of the units. (Smells like eminent domain to me.) Is your landlord trying to evict you? Have no fear. The process can take up to 18 months. You’ve got nothing but time!

Meanwhile, these warm and cozy communist policies have led the NYC Housing Authority to report that in 2026, rent collection dropped to 50%. It’s a cute little scheme: they raised rent so you couldn’t pay it, blamed the landlords, seized once-private property, and took more control. 

Good job, everyone. 

Campaign Promise #4: Tax the Rich (and the Not-So-Rich)

Well, he tried, but he’s running out of other people’s money, so middle class, you’re up! Mamdani promised a 2% tax on millionaires that would magically generate $9 billion a year, plus a higher corporate tax, to pay for the nonexistent free buses and universal childcare. New Yorkers got a pied-à-terre tax on second homes instead. After exposing the names and addresses of the 26,000 property owners he’d be plundering, he triumphantly announced on Tuesday that he’d sent out $500 million in bills. The problem: sending a bill isn’t the same as collecting it. His own city comptroller expects only about $350 million to roll in, a fraction of what he promised.

He also never bothered to specify where that money would go… because Socialists don’t care about helping the poor. They care about punishing the prosperous.

And in the process, they punish everyone. Ever heard of congestion pricing? It’s a fee charged to vehicles, delivery drivers included, entering busy zones, which in New York means all the time. Mamdani is celebrating the planned increase from $9 to $12 in 2028, despite pleas from restaurant and theater owners to hold the line.

Double, double, toll and trouble: fire burn and wallet bubble.

Speaking of delivery drivers, Amazon and small businesses are screwed. The Marxist mayor is now pushing the Delivery Protection Act, which would effectively end Amazon’s use of local delivery partners in the city and cost households $664 a year. Protective, indeed.

Campaign Promise #5: City-Run Grocery Stores

We can’t forget the infamous “cheap eggs and bread” shops, an idea he apparently lifted straight from 1920s Soviet Russia. Ten months after the lip service, not one of his five promised stores is open, which may be a blessing, since they’re ruinous for small businesses and consumers alike. The one slated to open in 2029 is projected to cost taxpayers $30 million, when all five were supposed to cost $70 million total. The math doesn’t math. (It never does for socialists.)

Private-sector jobs are down 16,300 so far this year. Nearly $11 billion in revenue has vanished. Homeless New Yorkers are freezing to death. And free childcare carries a price tag of $5.9 billion.

Scientific conclusion? Hypothesis confirmed. It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, and the second year hasn’t even started.

Welcome to New York.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip