Sports

What If MLB Owners Aren’t Really Chasing A Salary Cap? Could ‘Plan B’ Be The Real Goal?

What if this has all been just a high-profile, big-swing negotiating tactic and nothing more?

Sport & State
Listen
Listen
5 min
What If MLB Owners Aren’t Really Chasing A Salary Cap? Could ‘Plan B’ Be The Real Goal?
Photo by Patrick McDermott/Getty Images

This article was written by Jason Foster and published on Sport & State, a new media company founded by Clay Travis that is built around sports, culture, original voices, and live conversation.* * * * *

Labor negotiations often come with theater as both sides make big pronouncements, trade barbs and insults, threaten to walk, and have dramatic give and take before they ultimately settle on a deal.

But sometimes, before that final agreement, there’s also deception, as one side or the other backs off a big ask late in the process to seem as though they’re making a significant sacrifice, when in reality that big ask was never the true goal but something used to make the real prize more digestible when unveiled.

With that in mind, here’s a thought exercise: As we head toward a certain MLB lockout and some very contentious collective bargaining negotiations, what if the owners aren’t really after a salary cap?

What?!

Seriously, hear me out.

Obviously, the owners want a salary cap. It’s been their white whale for more than 30 years. Commissioner Rob Manfred even said Wednesday that he “can’t imagine” the owners approving any proposal without a cap and floor. It’s what you’d expect him to say, especially four months before there’s any serious threat to the 2027 season. But the message has been clear for a while: They really mean it this time!

Here’s the thing, though: The owners know they won’t get a cap, at least not without some drastic development, given the players union’s solidarity going back decades. So what if “Plan B” has always been Plan A?

What if this has all been just a high-profile, big-swing negotiating tactic and nothing more? It’s a thought worth considering.

The MLB Players Association has been adamantly against a cap for decades, despite being the only major North American league without one. It’s always been a non-starter, no matter what carrots the owners may float (shorter season, higher minimum salary, etc.).

And despite both sides indicating that they’d potentially sacrifice an entire season to win the negotiations, I don’t think either is actually willing to do that.

MORE: In MLB’s salary cap propaganda war, players must offer more than stubborn refusals

There’s way too much immediate money to be lost for both sides if MLB went dark for a year, not to mention the long-term effects of a sports public that would learn to live without baseball. That’s why I think there’s a decent chance the owners back off a cap just in time to play something at least close to a full season.

But what might “Plan B” look like? It’s hard to say. But there’s likely no one big thing that would replace a cap, but perhaps a combination of things that could be included with, for example, a higher minimum salary and a quicker path to free agency.

A possible package could include …

(I have no inside knowledge here; I’m just spitballing.)

• A reworked luxury tax with harsher penalties: Maybe the new plan actually has teeth and sends a lot more money to smaller-market teams when the Dodgers, Mets or Yankees exceed the limit. Maybe there are other levers, too.

• Better media revenue: Maybe the owners have come up with a plan to distribute TV money so smaller markets benefit in a meaningful way while still allowing the big markets to keep some of their revenue.

• Expanded playoffs: They’ve already proposed a version of expanded playoffs, but maybe they want to expand the field to 14 teams and expand the LDS to a best-of-seven. More interest, more big games, more big money. (I actually have a good plan for a 14-team playoff.)

• Radical realignment: This has been bandied about for a while, but maybe they have an actual desire and plan to do it. Teams switch leagues and everything’s about geography. Maybe they even drop leagues entirely in favor of conferences. Maybe the plan reduces teams’ travel to the point of saving a ton of money.

• Some kind of mid-season tournament, ala the NBA: Maybe owners want a 150-game season and a weeklong tournament in July. Maybe it replaces the All-Star Game. Or maybe it’s in addition to the All-Star Game. Either way, it’s more TV and more money.

Again, consider this brainstorming. A possibility. A desire. Maybe even a fantasy.

Maybe the ultimate result doesn’t look anything like this. Maybe the owners back off a cap (like usual) and they just continue to make do under a system that’s just a marginal improvement over what they have now.

Or maybe there is no Plan B and a salary cap/floor really is the only play this time. If so, we could be in for a much darker and colder winter than usual — and a baseball-less spring that’s noticeably less joyful.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip