Things Fall Apart: Trust, Prep, And Don’t Eat Your Neighbors
Credit: The Daily Wire

DW Opinion

Things Fall Apart: Trust, Prep, And Don’t Eat Your Neighbors

Balance the reality of the moment without invalidating real fears.

Ben Domenech
Listen
Listen
20 min

Peter Meijer served as the U.S. representative for Michigan’s 3rd congressional district from 2021 to 2023. He also served in the U.S. Army Reserves and, while a student at Columbia University, deployed to Iraq in 2010 to conduct intelligence operations. As a member of Team Rubicon, he led humanitarian and crisis management efforts worldwide, including in New York after Superstorm Sandy, Oklahoma after a series of devastating tornadoes, and the Philippines following Super Typhoon Yolanda. In this Punch interview, he talks with Ben Domenech about the cascading failures of technology infrastructure across multiple U.S. industries, whether this is a sign that America is under attack, what response we should expect from our leaders, and what the American people can do to assuage their fears in an uncertain time.

***

Ben Domenech: Let’s start with this. The general mood in the country right now seems to be one of panic, and it seems to be fomented by a lot of different elements of this and things that are combining to seem like a cascade of coincidences, which now makes people feel like they aren’t coincidences. What’s your overall response to the way that this mood has grown, and what do you think is really behind it?

Peter Meijer: Obviously, this is before we get into what actually may be behind the outages and the disruptions. Media loves a good story. Before, we were all worried about social media algorithms fine-tuning our dopamine receptors to continuously want something to happen. You have the idea that if it bleeds, it leads. And then there’s very little incentive to be calibrated or measured or cautious in really any way, shape, or form. So naturally, if something hit, those receptors are going to have the media amplifying it. And I also think that there’s just a generalized angst that — is it social media? Is it the threat of massive disruption? Is it just the sort of technological era we’re living in? We’ve had this generalized angst, in some ways — post 9/11 and, in other, more acute ways, post-COVID — in ways that I think we haven’t really fully reconciled with what that did to us as a society psychologically, that sense of waiting for the other shoe to drop, which, I spent time in finance and investments and in that broader market, there’s been this idea that the recession is just around the corner — it’s going to be the next 2008 global financial crisis. That has been the operating hypothesis across the markets for the better part of 15 years, which, ironically in some ways, the more you are worried about that thing happening, the more you’re keeping your guard up, the less you’re getting irrationally exuberant, the more you’re ironically decreasing the likelihood of that happening because you’re not taking the risks that could potentially precipitate this financial crisis.

So I think of that mentality and then porting it over to the broader culture where you have both some of the Frontier Lab CEOs and employees talking about how dramatically AI is going to change things sometimes in optimistic terms, oftentimes in less optimistic terms. And then when you start to see this layered on, the disruptions that are explained and kind of waved away in the moment, but happening one after another, it not only cues into that greater concern and anxiety about where we’re going, but then it also hits upon a deeper mistrust in the institutions to the point where even all of the explanations that have been given so far are plausible. They make sense on their face, and yet the trust is not there.

BD: How much of this is driven by a lack of knowledge, and therefore by ascribing enormous power to entities to affect lasting and immediate damage to major things people rely on? I’ve had more conversations in the last month about America’s power grid and the possibility of losing power for months at a time and things of that nature — people who’ve come up with reasons why that could happen. I’ve had more conversations about something I thought of as being an old thing that we used to worry about in my days in the War on Terror era of dirty bombs, most recently fomented again with this CNN report. You’ve had a real attitude that everything happening is happening for a reason, and that it’s either driven by malevolent intent from overseas or by malevolent intent from independent hacking actors.

Why do you think people jump to those conclusions instead of the conclusion I tend to jump to, which is that someone in the chain here was an idiot?

PM: Well, just because you’re paranoid doesn’t mean they’re not watching you, or doesn’t mean they’re not following you. The paranoid response to this could be the accurate one. So nothing I’m going to say should be interpreted as dismissing that or saying that I fully agree that all of these are just independent coincidences, but it is sort of a universal truism that a reason why conspiracy theories have purchase is that it’s a lot more soothing to believe that the things that are happening are happening because of intention than accident. And if you believe in a higher power that’s benevolent, that can help you make sense of and find peace with the world. If you believe in a greater power, a hidden force that is malevolent, that’s a lot more soothing than believing that, yes, somebody screwed up here. They didn’t think through this thing over there. Mistakes happen. Have you met people? Sometimes they do a great job, other times they don’t. That reality of the messiness of life is a difficult thing to grapple with, especially if you are having to understand that messiness within a very complicated, complex system that you not only do not understand, but some of the people who are experts and professionals in that also talk about not understanding. And in that black box — and technology, AI, is the ultimate black box — in that black box, it is only natural to jump to the most problematic conclusions. And that can actually be healthy if your assumption is that some malevolent force is going to try to manipulate a system, is going to hack into something that we’re all vulnerable to. You take precautions that may go overboard at times, but in the main are entirely reasonable, entirely rational. And again, it could help forestall the very concern that you’re dealing with.

So in this case, if it’s, “Hey, we had an outage over here; it was caused by an update. We had another thing over here — the patch we implemented was a little rushed, so it didn’t have the results we were anticipating.” You had something else occurring with a similar explanation… I go by either Occam’s razor: the simplest explanation is the right one, or the most logical, or by Hanlon’s razor: never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

I think to me it’s Occam’s razor for a number of the things that we’re seeing, which doesn’t mean that it’s all of them, but for a number of the things that we’re seeing that the government’s given that, hey, this is not necessarily caused by AI so much as us responding to the threat that AI poses and rushing crashes into our systems based on vulnerabilities that AI discovered that we discovered that could be exploited by somebody else. And so we are updating, we are patching, we are trying to fix these systems at a much more rapid clip — that is, keeping up with or trying to keep up with the pace of artificial intelligence development. That’s why things are breaking because we’re patching them and fixing them at a rate that we haven’t before. To me, that holds a lot of water. And again, that may not explain everything, but if you were truly an adversary wanting to attack, which is to be clear, different from an adversary that’s probing, that is looking for vulnerabilities, if this was an out-and-out attack, you wouldn’t be able to fix it in a couple of hours. It would most likely be far more disruptive than the temporary inconveniences we’ve seen over the last week.

BD: The idea that you should pull all your money out of the banks because some people had difficulty accessing their accounts for less than half an hour doesn’t strike me as a very wise response, personally.

PM: But if you think of some of the guidance that’s been given, and you saw this propagating where the U.K. is warning their citizens to have three days of food and water on hand, something else is happening over here, something else is happening over there. All of that is just traditional longstanding guidance that is good to have. It’s smart and rational to have sufficient food on hand, whether it’s because of an AI attack, a cyber attack that cripples systems, or a natural disaster. Having that internal redundancy is good. So if this encourages people to pay attention to guidance that the government’s been giving for decades that they’ve neglected, that’s not bad.

BD: I completely agree with you, and it seems to me that having those sorts of basic plans has always been good advice. And the truth is that the power can go out because of a bad storm. We’ve had it go out all the time where we live, to the point where I upgraded some of the backup energy that we’ve gotten. And that’s because in a lot of cases you’re living in a place that’s combining new things and old things, and that’s a problem. And it’s particularly a problem, I would say, when it comes to air travel. The response to that one, because of the nationwide ground stoppage and because of immediately having tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of people trying to figure out what was going on, that one to me has been an area where the administration has done a really poor job of responding to it, especially when the knee-jerk is to just give it more money.

What should they be doing better in messaging, particularly around that area of concern, given that so many people are currently debating whether to fly home for the holidays?

PM: Number one, don’t speculate. I think if something happens and you look to leadership and leadership seems unaware or is trying to downplay or is otherwise not sympathetic to the concerns that people are facing, very quickly what you then start to do is you don’t look to them. You lose trust if you had it; your lack of trust you feel is validated. When it comes to air travel, the number one goal is not to have every plane flying all the time. The number one goal is safety and air travel is incredibly safe. And one of the reasons why it’s safe is when there is an issue that arises, the response isn’t damn the torpedoes, let’s fly at all costs. It’s hold on, let’s take a breather. Let’s figure out if this is going to have a safety impact.

And so I think a lot of the ways in which the FAA responded was smart, was logical, was good. But you also, especially in this moment, especially when news travels immensely quickly, somebody should be briefing from a podium in a proper, formal, professional-looking scenario, not going on Fox News.

That’s fine, that’s a good supplement, but show that folks are burning the midnight oil, show that people are working around the clock in D.C., and that we’ve got top men on the job. That should be the impression sent to the American people. And so I think especially when a lot of these are — even if the common thread is this patching and upgrading to address vulnerabilities that have been found, even if it’s in that most innocent case — the administration should have one point person. It shouldn’t be the president because conveying very complex information in a soothing tone is not his strength.

Frankly, it should probably be Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton. He’s somebody who has the stature. Identify a point person who’s going to take the lead; they can work alongside whichever agencies make the most sense. I don’t even know who’s running the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency [CISA] right now. If that’s somebody who has that stature, that’s a very logical person to do it. But the “ready-for-primetimeness” of political appointees is always a bit of a mixed bag. And somebody could be excellent at their job and just not be the public face that you need. So that’s not me impugning the reputation of competence in that position. But having one trusted face that is speaking only from what is known, that if they’re offering an assessment, it can be trusted, and that, most importantly, is not viewed as a political figure, is very important in this moment.

And until the administration both treats this with a sense of urgency that hasn’t necessarily been conveyed by their public-facing approach, and has put somebody in that role who stands to gain nothing from it politically, who is not associated with partisan politics and can just be that sort of trusted single source of truth, you’re going to continue to have a lot of doubt, hesitation, and speculation from all corners. It doesn’t mean that this is coming after a midterm in which the GOP and this administration, in particular, didn’t get a very clear and resounding lack of disapproval from the public at large. Building back that confidence is going to be difficult, and it needs to be done exceptionally well. And this is doubly frustrating because if there ever was an administration with incredibly sharp people who have access and have relationships with the best technological minds on the planet and, frankly, in the history of humanity, it’s this administration.

There are some incredible people who are there, but you’re not going to get that if it’s folks who, again, are more associated with the letter next to their name than with the professional accomplishments they’ve had to date.

BD: One aspect of this that, of course, raises people’s concerns the most is anything associated with national security. There is always a give and take there where we don’t want to be as open with the American people necessarily about what’s going on or what we are doing because we want to continue to do it in a responsible way, whether that’s fixing internal security issues or things of that nature. So when it comes to the security side of this, how do you message around that? Because that’s obviously the area where people’s minds run the most roughshod in the direction of only bad things.

PM: That is where it is the hardest, the narrowest tightrope to walk because if you — we saw this with COVID, we saw this with Fauci — publicly, there’s either hesitation, or there’s nuance. So privately, there’s either hesitation or nuance or a different degree of confidence associated with something. And publicly, they are saying if you utter anything along the lines of what we ourselves are thinking, that is disinformation, misinformation, and will result in you getting deplatformed. That’s not healthy; that’s not good. Then you overlay that with — if they say this is all routine, we’re on it, and really this was an adversarial attack that they’re somehow masking, that’ll come out eventually, and that will further just take a blowtorch to whatever residual trust the American people may have. Now there may be very good reasons why you don’t want to take that path or why you need to keep some things private. There are always good reasons, but those have to be strongly balanced against number one, the guarantee of eventual disclosure, and number two, the fact that it is in almost every circumstance far better to be honest, to be clear, to be upfront with the American people from the jump. If you are not, you have to have damn good reasons to do that because the negative consequences over time almost always exceed whatever minor gain was had in that moment.

There are things that, as somebody goes on TV a fair bit, I have hunches, and I have inclinations that I, not because I necessarily am privy to classified information or anything along those lines, but because there could be something else afoot… It is a very fine line. It is an exceedingly fine line that has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

Balancing the reality of a moment with also not trying to invalidate the fears that people may have, which could be well-founded or could not be well-founded, but understanding that your job as a public official is to both accurately convey truthful information as you understand it, and to correct the record as soon as that understanding may change or additional information comes out.

But it’s not just the realm of the facts; it’s also understanding the feelings and the anxiety and working to soothe and have those feelings and anxiety be calibrated accurately rather than: oh, people are afraid, so we’re just going to try to make them not afraid. They have good reasons to be concerned. The cybersecurity threats are real. The vulnerability of our infrastructure is real. Nobody in national security would pretend for a second that the soft belly of our economic and national security is — our broader, our great system, in some ways our banking system, healthcare system — all of those critical systems are likely to be a front in any significant conflict and are already a front in the non-existential conflicts that we’re engaged in right now. And so it’s a matter of having the trust built and the connection with the people to make sure that their fears are rational and their feelings are not taken for granted or dismissed unnecessarily.

BD: When you do see these things playing out in front of us with the people who are truly panicking, who are truly terrified about what’s going on, how is it possible to communicate to them that, to a certain degree, if it turns out that their suspicions are of negative foreign actors or some sort of organized effort on the part of anti-American interests to foment this kind of panic, that they’re doing exactly what America’s enemies want them to do?

PM: That is the essence of terrorism: you want to undermine and stoke fear far more than the actual consequences of whatever act you’ve committed. And I think that’s where, again, you have to have — and when I say you have to have, I’m not saying you should trust somebody without earning that trust. The people need to trust the government, but the government needs to build and retain that trust with the people. It’s a two-way street. This is where the irrational panic — which, again, some of this panic, some of the fears, some of the panic, some of the reactions to this — if those are in line with, again, what people should be doing as a normal course to prepare for contingencies, that’s good. At the same time, the panic that goes beyond that into things that could actually cause the outcome that the panic is intended to prevent, right? That’s the challenge, when people start to hoard things, and then you have shortages, and then people take the scarcity mentality and do even more hoarding, and then you have even more shortages, and the panic itself can drive the outcome that, on a general level, but on an individual level, is intended to be prevented.

It’s important to just be realistic about things, to think back to COVID. I mean, I bought — because I could only find it in a 24-pack — of deodorant during COVID. I just finished the last stick from that COVID era thing. So let’s keep in mind what preparations we did back in March of 2020 that were like, “Oh, that was a smart and good thing to do.” And a lot of the things were just like, “Okay, yeah, we may have gotten a little bit over our skis.” It’s probably a good reason to do some of your Black Friday shopping early, to also not put too much strain on the shipping systems.

It’s a good opportunity to evaluate on a household level, but don’t do things where, five days from now, or five months from now, you’ll look back and, to paraphrase Alex Jones: “Oh boy, I may have resorted to eating my neighbors a little bit too quickly.”

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip