Russell Brand’s Old Fans On The Left Don’t Get To Play Defenders Of Women Now
Photo by Zeynep Demir/Anadolu via Getty Images

Upstream

Russell Brand’s Old Fans On The Left Don’t Get To Play Defenders Of Women Now

Brand’s sexual behavior was perfectly acceptable to the Left back then. It was his political transformation that made him unacceptable.

Meghan Murphy
Listen
Listen
8 min

As a darling of the Left, Russell Brand joked endlessly about treating women as little more than vessels for his debauched proclivities. He made no secret of his use of prostitutes, detailing the story of a trip to Hong Kong with his father, who paid three women to have sex with him and his then-17-year-old son. Brand saw this as a turning point, leading him toward “sex addiction.” In his 2007 autobiography, “My Booky Wook,” Brand says this is when his sexuality went from “bewildered innocence into something more complex and rapacious.”

He was open about his predatory approach to sex with women, more broadly, joking endlessly in his comedy about “dragging women into the toilet” and about enjoying the kind of oral sex that makes a woman gag, “where mascara runs a little bit,” he specified during a 2006 stand-up tour.

Last week, Brand was sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison after being found guilty of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault. The comedian relayed a message of innocence from behind bars, read by his wife, Laura, on Sunday: “Beloved brothers and sisters in Christ, God bless you for your support. As you know, I am not guilty for the offenses I have been jailed for, so something strange is happening.”

The allegations against Brand are numerous. He was not just extremely promiscuous, but very pushy, with little concern for conventional or even, allegedly, communicated boundaries. He admitted to having had a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old girl when he was 30. The woman, who previously took the pseudonym “Alice,” has since gone public as Mia Latter, and is now campaigning for a change in age-of-consent laws. Brand admits the relationship was exploitative, in retrospect, though not illegal.

In April, at 50 years old, Brand told Megyn Kelly: “The plain fact of it is, in Europe and in the United Kingdom, where I’m from, the age of consent is 16. And I did sleep with a 16-year-old when I was 30. … But when I was 30, I was a very different person. I was a lot younger, and I was an immature 30-year-old.”

“It is exploitative,” Brand said of his behavior. “Consensual sex with a lot of people, when there is a strong power differential, as there is when you are a famous man who has the ability to attract women that I had at that time, I think involves exploitation.”

It is good that Brand can see his past sexual behavior was unethical, but he continues to insist it was all consensual. And he may be right, though clearly the judge disagreed. Who is correct is not for me to determine, but I will say that my judgment is not limited to Brand’s immoral behavior.

Again, none of this proves he is a rapist. I imagine at least most of the women Brand engaged with sexually were enthusiastic in their desire to be with a celebrity like Brand. Perhaps regretfully, in retrospect. And perhaps some were left traumatized by their experience. What Brand’s boasting persona does prove is that the condemnation now expressed by many of those who worked and socialized with Brand is bull.

The rumors surrounding the comedian are not new. Everyone around the man knew who he was, and either wasn’t bothered by it, or didn’t see it as professionally or personally beneficial to say anything. The prominent leftist politicians and media figures who enjoyed that Brand toed their line didn’t care about his misogynist comments or his sexual behavior back then; are we to believe they suddenly grew a conscience? Of course not. 

It was the Left that determined anything goes sexually, provided those involved signed the proverbial dotted line. Or at the very least didn’t scream, “No!” But this has always been a not just pathetic, but dangerous, ethical standard. Just because a person agrees to be abused doesn’t mean you should do it. Just because a woman doesn’t demand respectful treatment in the bedroom or in an intimate relationship doesn’t mean it’s OK to treat her badly. Just because a woman accepts payment doesn’t mean a blow job that makes her choke is above board. Paying someone to participate in a traumatic experience or simply convincing her to do so for free doesn’t mean your moral inquiries should end there.

Yet this is what the Left insists. Is it any wonder Brand thought his behavior was acceptable? This is precisely what he — and all the rest of us who came of age during that time — were told by the people who claim moral high ground. Liberals set the very standards at which they are now expressing horror.

I have bashed my head against the wall for well over a decade attempting to explain to the Left and to third-wave feminists that violent and degrading pornography is harmful regardless of whether or not the women on the other side of the screen agreed to participate, to no avail. I have insisted that sex is not “simply a job like any other,” as in fact the sex trade is founded on the horrific abuse and exploitation of countless women and children, globally, and paying someone for sex is never ethical. I have argued that sexualizing abuse in BDSM is not a harmless practice and that normalizing “kink” in public was grotesque and dangerous.

Democrats told me over and over again I was a regressive prude, attempting to control the fun times of sexual liberals. Their political faction has since taken up the #MeToo mantle and claimed they are the party fighting “rape culture” in response to their suspiciously timed Cornell Seven scandal, as well as in many other activist campaigns including the ridiculous pink hat march following Donald Trump’s 2016 election, which imagined the Republican Party as particularly dangerous to women. This is as enraging as it is nonsensical.

These people have told me for over a decade that paying an abused, addicted, and traumatized woman to perform degrading sex acts is completely ethical and deserves no further thought on account of “consent.” Now they want to play virtuous defenders of women in response to Brand’s sentencing.

Last week, Netflix released a documentary about the allegations called “Russell Brand: Open Secret.” The film concluded with derision at the comedian’s political turn toward “conspiracy theories and the far right.”

“He’s now providing a channel for some really odious far-right people,” Guardian columnist George Monbiot complained, as an image of U.K. activist Tommy Robinson flashed across the screen, followed by a clip of Brand at Mar-a-Lago. Monbiot praised Brand as a “hero” in 2014, writing, “He’s the best thing that has happened to the left in years.” The sexual behavior was perfectly acceptable to Monbiot back then. It was Brand’s political transformation that made the comedian unacceptable. Monbiot described it as “one of the most troubling things I’ve ever come across in my life.”

The disdain toward Joe Rogan-esque podcasters is palpable. Critics frame Brand’s turn as a strategic but disreputable grift — ice baths! meditation! conspiracies! — but it’s clear that what they have a problem with is his critiques of mainstream media and the threat that alternative media poses to their longstanding dominance over the narrative.

That audience has been labeled “odious” by the liberals who embraced, platformed, and paid Brand while he promoted their leftist views. To claim now that it is their chosen political enemies who are accepting of Brand’s sexual behavior is a repulsive joke — one of many they clearly don’t mind.

***

Meghan Murphy is a writer from Vancouver, now living in Mexico. Find more of her work at www.meghanmurphy.ca.

This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip