Republican Saritha Komatireddy is betting that New Yorkers are more interested in public safety, government accountability, and prosecutorial independence than partisan politics — and after a debate in which Democrat Attorney General Letitia James stumbled over a softball question, the former federal prosecutor is pointing to an internal campaign poll showing a single-digit race in the final stretch.
(Will Waldron/Albany Times Union via Getty Images)
Komatireddy, a first-time candidate who prosecuted cases involving terrorism, cybercrime, narcotics trafficking, money laundering, and public corruption, is challenging James’ bid for another term as New York’s top law enforcement officer. Her campaign has focused on crime, homelessness, fraud, and what she describes as the politicization of the attorney general’s office.
A poll conducted by OnMessage Inc. from October 12–14 found James leading Komatireddy by just six points, 50.7% to 44.7%, with approximately 4% undecided. The survey of 1,000 likely voters had a margin of error of 2.8 percentage points, according to the New York Post, which first reported the results. Earlier polling had shown James leading by double digits.
CHECK OUT THE DAILY WIRE MIDTERM HUB
The survey also found that Komatireddy led James 81% to 19% among respondents who watched their October 8 debate. However, only one in five respondents said they had watched it. Among those who did not, James led 59% to 36%.
The numbers — from a pollster the Post said received an “A rating” from Nate Silver during the 2024 election cycle — offer Komatireddy a path to an upset, though the poll was commissioned by her own campaign. The most recent independent poll, a September Siena survey taken before the debate, showed James leading 52% to 39%, in a state where Republicans have not won a statewide election in more than two decades.
One of the debate’s most memorable exchanges came when moderator Errol Louis asked James to name a former New York attorney general she admired.
James paused for several seconds before Louis joked, “Tick tock,” prompting laughter from James. Komatireddy seized the opening. “She only admires herself,” she quipped.
James subsequently named former Democratic Attorney General Bob Abrams, who served from 1979 to 1993, and said she admired past attorneys general generally because the job requires difficult decisions and standing up for one’s principles. Komatireddy, meanwhile, named former Republican Attorney General Dennis Vacco, who served from 1995 to 1998.
The exchange became a viral moment for Komatireddy’s campaign, reinforcing her argument that James has spent too much time pursuing national political fights and too little time focusing on the responsibilities of her office.
Komatireddy also accused James of politicizing the office.
“New Yorkers, you do not have an attorney general right now,” she said during the debate. “For the last eight years, you’ve had a political hack sitting in the chair using our taxpayer money for her political purposes.”
James responded by arguing that Komatireddy did not understand the responsibilities of the office and defending her record.
Komatireddy spent much of her career as a federal prosecutor in the Eastern District of New York, handling cases involving international terrorism, cybercrime, narcotics trafficking, money laundering, and public corruption. She also served as chief of staff for the Drug Enforcement Administration.
Komatireddy has made that background central to her campaign, arguing that she would redirect the attorney general’s office toward public safety and criminal enforcement.
During an October 15 interview with the New York Editorial Board, a Substack publication, Komatireddy said she had traveled to all 62 New York counties and heard recurring concerns about repeat offenders, homelessness, and fraud. She argued that New Yorkers feel less safe than they did before the COVID-19 pandemic and cited state criminal justice data showing an increase in total index crimes between 2019 and 2024.
Komatireddy said the office has approximately 700 assistant attorneys general but assigns fewer than 100 to criminal prosecution. She wants to increase that number to roughly 350, making criminal enforcement a much larger part of the office’s work. She also argued that the attorney general has the authority to intervene in certain cases involving local prosecutors when the law provides special jurisdiction, including qualifying hate-crime cases.
Komatireddy has also criticized Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, accusing his office of reducing charges in cases that should carry more serious penalties.
James has built a national profile through litigation against President Donald Trump and his administration, making her one of the most prominent Democratic attorneys general in the country.
Her office brought a civil fraud case against Trump and the Trump Organization, alleging that they fraudulently inflated asset valuations to obtain financial benefits. In 2025, a state appeals court threw out the nearly $500 million civil penalty against Trump, though a majority of the panel agreed he was liable for fraud. James has appealed to the state’s highest court.
James has also joined multistate lawsuits challenging Trump administration policies on funding, immigration, education, and other matters. Supporters describe those cases as necessary efforts to enforce the law and protect New Yorkers from unlawful federal actions. Komatireddy argues that the office has become too focused on national political battles at the expense of local public safety.
James’ handling of sensitive criminal matters has also drawn scrutiny. Gov. Kathy Hochul appointed her as a special prosecutor in the investigation of an alleged 2024 gang rape at a Cornell University fraternity. The appointment prompted questions about impartiality. Lawyers for two of the accused students have pressed for her removal, citing a social media post in which she expressed support for the accuser. James defended her comments as expressions of empathy.
Separately, Daniel Wiesenfeld, a former prosecutor in James’ office, claimed in an August email to colleagues that he was directed to pursue crimes by people and groups tied to Trump without a credible basis. James’ office denied the allegations and fired him in September, saying he was dismissed for cause. Wiesenfeld says the firing was retaliation. Komatireddy cited the allegations during her editorial board interview, arguing that the office must be guided by evidence and law rather than politics.
James’ campaign has countered that Komatireddy is aligned with Trump and would fail to hold the president accountable. A campaign spokeswoman told the New York Post that Komatireddy “wouldn’t protect New Yorkers from fraudsters or the federal government, because they’re the ones propping up her candidacy.”
Komatireddy faces a formidable political map. New York has not elected a Republican to statewide office since 2002, and James retains a significant advantage in New York City, where the OnMessage poll showed James leading 65% to 30%.
The same survey, however, found Komatireddy ahead on Long Island, in the broader downstate suburbs, and upstate. She also led among independent voters, 49% to 43%, according to the poll.
She has also challenged James to participate in additional televised debates outside New York City, arguing that voters across the state deserve more opportunities to hear the candidates defend their records. “Letitia James has had nearly eight years to make her case to New Yorkers,” Komatireddy said after the debate. “She should have no problem spending another hour defending her record.”
.png)
.png)
