How Trump’s New Seafood Strategy Will Save Our Coastal Towns And Your Dinner Plate
Credit: Getty Images

DW Opinion

How Trump’s New Seafood Strategy Will Save Our Coastal Towns And Your Dinner Plate

Time to cast away dirty foreign fish farms and reel in fresh U.S. seafood.

Bonnie Brady
Listen
Listen
6 min

Every morning, American commercial fishermen head out to sea to harvest one of the healthiest protein sources available: U.S. wild-caught seafood. Fish, shellfish, and crustaceans that have spent their lives swimming freely, feeding naturally, and are harvested under some of the strictest conservation standards in the world.

Yet millions of Americans will eat seafood tonight without knowing where it came from, who caught it, or how it was produced.

President Trump’s America First Seafood Strategy offers an opportunity to change that by reconnecting consumers with American fishermen and the extraordinary seafood harvested off our shores.

But there’s another reason to know where your fish comes from. More than 80% of seafood consumed in America is imported, and some is produced under tepid environmental, labor, and food-safety standards.

Before that fish hits your pan, take a look inside the pen. Fish crowded into underwater pens produce feces, uneaten feed and sludge that can smother the seafloor, deplete oxygen, and pollute surrounding waters. Disease spreads in crowded conditions, and some producers rely heavily on antibiotics, raising concerns about drug residues.

The contamination doesn’t stop at the cages, as waste, pathogens, and parasites like sea lice can spread into surrounding waters and threaten wild marine life. When storms or damaged nets allow farmed fish to escape, they can carry disease, compete with wild populations and even interbreed with native fish. Once farmed fish escape into the ocean, no electric collar is bringing them back. Concerns about these threats to wild Pacific salmon have prompted Canada to move toward ending open-net-pen salmon farming in British Columbia’s coastal waters by 2029.

Farmed salmon receive feed containing pigments that give pale flesh the pink color consumers expect. Tuna can be “gassed” with carbon monoxide to preserve its red appearance, potentially making older fish look fresher. But lipstick on an old, imported tuna steak is still lipstick.

And then there’s #SlaveShrimp. In 2016, the Associated Press won the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service after exposing slavery in Southeast Asia’s seafood industry. Burmese workers, including young women and girls, were locked inside filthy Thai shrimp-peeling factories, forced to work under threats of violence, processing shrimp destined for American supermarkets and restaurants. The investigation helped free more than 2,000 workers. Separate investigations have raised forced-labor and sanitation concerns in India’s shrimp industry.

Not every imported or farmed fish presents these problems. But Americans deserve to know what they’re buying.

Compare that with the American fisherman.

Under the Magnuson-Stevens Act and other conservation laws, scientists assess stocks, managers set catch limits, and fishermen follow restrictions designed to prevent overfishing and protect marine ecosystems. American wild-caught seafood is the gold standard in responsible fisheries management, providing protein, vitamins, minerals, and, in many species, omega-3 fatty acids. Wild fish need no manufactured feed, pigmentation, or antibiotics during production.

From lobster and haddock to shrimp, squid and stone crab, every region offers specialties. But how many Americans have tried them? Most recognize salmon, tuna and cod. Far fewer know redfish, a tender, flaky alternative to expensive imports, or scup, also called porgy, a delicious, mild white fish caught along the Mid-Atlantic coast.

The best seafood bargain at your fish market might be a fish you’ve never heard of.

Ask your fishmonger, “What’s fresh, local, in season, and a good deal today?” You might discover fluke, monkfish, whiting, bluefish or squid. Grilled Atlantic halibut or homemade calamari can deliver a delicious meal without breaking the bank.

That’s what the strategy’s proposed “Eat American Seafood” campaign and “U.S. Caught Seafood” designation can accomplish: helping consumers recognize American seafood and appreciate its value.

Every purchase of American-landed seafood supports crews, dealers, packhouses, processors, truckers, boatyards, dockworkers, and coastal businesses. The strategy’s focus on processing, cold storage, and stronger markets will bring more American seafood to our tables.

Buying local seafood should be as natural as buying local produce, and just as easy. Hannaford supermarkets, started in Portland, Maine, by Arthur Hannaford in 1883 and prevalent in the Northeast, offer a great model, highlighting local, fresh U.S. seafood at their counters and giving shoppers choices such as redfish, pollock, and hake alongside familiar favorites like haddock and lobster.

A porgy in every frying pan. A lobster in every pot. American wild-caught seafood on every table. Let’s rebuild our fleets, revive our working waterfronts, and flip the 80/20 and replace more imports with American catch, together, reclaiming our place as a wild-caught seafood superpower. Let’s make U.S.-caught seafood great again!

***

Bonnie Brady is policy director of the New England Fishermen’s Stewardship Association.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip