Everyone is super pumped about the release at long last of Grand Theft Auto VI, the release of which has been 13 years in the making.
But as usual, I’m here to rain on everyone’s parade because I’ve been 80 years old since I was about eight.
I get the nostalgia. It’s been 13 years since the last Grand Theft Auto came out, and a ton of people played it when they were 12.
I also get the marketing campaign, which is legitimately the greatest marketing campaign in human history. You literally can’t check the weather right now without getting a GTA ad.
It turns out that capitalism always wins.
Men are taking time off from work to play GTA VI. They are asking their wives and kids to leave them alone so they can play it. Thirty-two percent of Gen Z workers and 27% of millennial workers plan to use paid time off to play the game.
I have nothing against enthusiasm for cultural events. When I was 17, it was Lord of the Rings.
But here’s where the fuddy-duddy comes in: GTA VI is bad. It is not good for you. It is not good for society.
We used to know that because GTA VI is about participating enthusiastically in random acts of criminality and evil.
That’s not great. Yes, of course it’s virtual. And no, I’m not saying that if you play GTA VI, you’re going to go out on the street and start murdering prostitutes.
But I am saying that if you could choose for your own kids what they do with their spare time, you would probably opt for something that makes them healthier or stronger or moral or better, or at least doesn’t give them gigantic dopamine hits for sinful behaviors.
Fun is not necessarily awesome for society or even for individuals. Lots of things are fun. I assume that’s why people do them. I assume heroin is fun for those who do it, and these are not great things.
But I want to get a little more specific because this is undeniably a giant cultural event – again, the biggest since the release of Lord of the Rings.
There are three reasons why GTA VI ain’t great.
First: celebrating or treating immorality with apathy is generally bad for a society.
Second: a world that caters to the worst impulses of young people — and yes, that includes young men — is a world that is aiming at suicidality.
Third (and this is always a challenge for all of us because we all do it to a certain extent): you damage your soul when you put crap in front of your eyes.
It’s pretty obvious that Americans have now accepted a higher level of basic immorality as something to celebrate. Our moral instinct, like our immune system, has generally left the building.
We should ask ourselves why Americans were scandalized by GTA V 13 years ago, but now everyone doesn’t just accept the moral universe of GTA VI, they actually celebrate the moral universe of GTA VI. The reviews are overwhelmingly positive.
The New York Times: “Grand Theft Auto VI will steal your heart.”
Oh.
The Guardian in the U.K.: “Gaming’s most depraved world is now also its greatest love story.”
Oh.
The New York Times writes:
Grand Theft Auto VI’s romantic leads, the vivacious Lucia Caminos and the gravel-voiced country boy Jason Duval, can hold hands with the press of a button. The prompt appears while walking down a busy downtown street, before reps at the gym, or after pulling on ski masks to rob an armored truck. This simple interaction, perhaps more than any of the innumerable things you can get up to in this immense experience, distinguishes the latest G.T.A. from what came before. This is a game about love and relationships, their joy and heartache, and the work required to make them successful.
Ah. You’re learning how to be a good spouse from GTA VI, according to The New York Times.
The surprising depth to which these themes are explored makes for a memorable and endearing experience in Grand Theft Auto VI, which largely lives up to its sky-high expectations by inverting the series’s reputation for destruction.
That’s so nice.
The Guardian:
I was astonished to discover the game offers you small incentives for acts of kindness, such as texting your partner a selfie, doing your neighbor a favor, or throwing your rubbish in the bin rather than dropping it on the ground. Jason and Lucia are not extravagant caricatures, but two people trying to make it in a world totally stacked against them. Pretty much everyone in this Floridian fever dream is a total crook, on the take mixed up in some bullshit scheme. It’s so easy to get away with crime in this city and so difficult to do things the right way.
They do admit that the game has thoroughly earned its adult rating: “Barely a half hour ever goes by without someone snorting coke off a knife blade, or some full frontal nudity. There are missions set inside a pornographer’s mansion and a small town strip club; you can visit those clubs and get a private dance (as either Jason or Lucia, for what it’s worth, or together).”
You know, like a nice couple would enjoy.
At one point, Lucia opens the wrong hotel room door to see a woman in a corset wielding a golf club, whacking balls at a guy’s testicles. On the in-game TV there’s a reality show about horny geriatrics. It is not so much pushing the boundaries of taste as to ignore the existence of taste.
It used to be that people objected to this sort of stuff. I know we’re dating ourselves now, but in 1993, there were Senate hearings on violent video games that ended with the industry having to create its own rating system. This game is rated “mature,” meaning you’re supposed to be 17 to play it.
Now let’s be real. As it turns out, most people who played GTA at any point in the past were younger than 17 at the time. Part of the marketing machine for the game was outrage.
There was violent crime litigation that began to mention GTA when there was teenage violence. Washington state passed a law in 2003 to restrict violent games to minors. It was struck down afterward on First Amendment grounds.
There used to be an aversion to this sort of stuff. There was a baseline recognition that if you were a kid, you shouldn’t be playing it.
What exactly happened here in the United States?
Ubiquity cancels out moral objections. That’s just a reality. If you surround people with something, they just get used to it.
It becomes part of the background noise.
So the taboos went away. There are still a few taboos. The makers of GTA VI are apparently fine with you murdering a random person at a subway station in the game; they just don’t want you shoving that person in front of a subway, because then people might remember that it actually happened and that would be offensive in some way.
You’re allowed to shoot people on the street, but not in a nightclub, because presumably you might remember the Pulse Orlando shooting. You can now hire strippers, and you can grab them by the a**, but you can’t hire a prostitute or murder them anymore because that generated a lot of blowback last time.
The underlying moral calculus of the game remains unchanged.
Is it great for society that all of these things have become mainstreamed? Is it great that if you heard a 12-, 13-, or 14-year-old was playing GTA VI, not only would you not be surprised, you’d be a little surprised if they weren’t?
We have now decided to cater to the desires of people who haven’t yet been civilized to the institutions and decisions that make people live worthwhile lives. We are creating entire product lines that cater to young people’s worst and most destructive impulses. In this case, we’re talking about young males because this is what GTA VI is: young male wish fulfillment.
We have been told that to curb those impulses is somehow a violation of the male prerogative.
The goal of a society shouldn’t be to wipe out the male aggressive instinct; it is to channel it into a more productive form. Marriage. Family. Children. Protecting. Producing.
One problem in Western society is that the feminist movement didn’t try to channel male drive in productive ways. It basically dismissed male drive as innately evil. In doing so, they actually uncivilized young men. They kept them as naked nomads because they destroyed the civilizational infrastructure that turns the naked nomads into productive builders. They got rid of marriage because, “Hey, a girl doesn’t need a man.” They got rid of fatherhood because, “Hey, kids don’t need dads.” They got rid of the usefulness of the police or the army: All the things that men traditionally do.
That’s all useless now. But that doesn’t mean that we are right as a society to celebrate and then feed the naked nomads.
Which, of course, is what GTA VI does.
Going back to the third reason: What you put in your head helps define you as a human being.
It helps to shape you. We realize this in most contexts, but then we ignore it. These things are not great for you. They do some level of spiritual damage.
It is worth saying that there are standards, and certain stuff just makes your soul dirty. Not all recreation is created equal. Watching pornography is not the same thing as watching “Casablanca.” It’s not a statement that you must watch “Casablanca.” It is a statement of basic obviousness.
GTA VI desensitizes players to basic immorality. The virtual world, in general, flattens all experiences. Even the most grotesque material becomes ordinary and routine or even funny. If you actually watched a person get eaten by a bear in front of you, it would not be funny. It would be terrifying.
The dopamine hit of a car chase or a fight scene will be less the hundredth time than the first. This happens with pornography as well. Habituation is a real thing, which is why there are a lot of guys who have real-life sexual problems because they watch too much pornography.
I’m not arguing that you’re going to go out and murder somebody on the street because you watched or played GTA VI, but your sensitivity to immoral behavior starts to wane.
The stuff that we put in our head matters as much as the stuff that we put in our bodies.
The Bible is very clear on this. In Numbers 15, God commands the Jews to wear ceremonial fringes because he says you’re supposed to look at them and recall God’s commandments and observe them, so you don’t follow your heart and your eyes in your urge to stray.
You’re literally supposed to have prophylactic things that you do to prevent you from putting bad stuff in your head via your eyeballs.
Philippians chapter four, verse eight: Paul says, “Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is gracious, if there is any excellence, and if there’s anything worthy of praise, think about those things.”
In Romans 12, Paul writes to Christians in Rome and says, “Do not conform yourselves to this age, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, that you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and pleasing and perfect.”
Both the Old and the New Testaments are filled with admonitions not to let your eyes linger on things that soil your soul.
There’s a reason for that, because the core innocence that you bear with you is something that is easily affected by the outside world, not just when you’re a kid, but also when you’re an adult.
The predictable effect of this kind of society is a blasé attitude toward morality.
As you move the taboo lines, the taboos shrink, and then you have to find the new taboo. And it’s even crazier than the old taboo, and you just keep moving that line farther out.
It’s bad for the soul of a human being, and it’s bad for the soul of a society.

Ben Shapiro
.png)
.png)

