WAKIL KOHSAR/AFP via Getty Images


‘Gross Abandonment’: Former Green Beret Tells Congress A High Price Was Paid For Chaotic Afghan Withdrawal


The following remarks were delivered by Lt. Col. (ret) Scott Mann at the House Foreign Affairs Committee hearing on the Afghanistan Withdrawal on March 8, 2023.

As a Green Beret and retired Lt. Col. with nearly 23 years in service and three combat tours in Afghanistan, I am here to relive August 2021 with all of you. Not as a Democrat or a Republican, but as an American veteran, representing 800,000 Afghan combat veterans, and their families, but with my own point of view.

I’d like to start with a question: What does an American promise mean today?

There is a promise in the military that is both explicit and implicit: “I have your back.” We were trained that way. It’s in our blood.

But, in August of 2021, the leaders who held us to that standard went silent while our Afghan allies were left behind. The U.S. government may not have had the backs of our Afghan allies. But our veterans did.

For as long as we’ve been a nation, our veterans have been a moral compass for doing the right thing, especially in hard times.

You won’t find many veterans who relished being involved in the Afghan evacuation. We paid our dues and moved on with our lives. Jumping back into the quagmire of Afghanistan was not part of my military retirement plan. 

But, like thousands of other veterans across the country watching Kabul collapse on August 15, 2021, I received a phone call from a friend that absolutely crushed me.

“I am not afraid to die,” he told me. “I just don’t want to die alone.”

Those were the words that dragged me back into Afghanistan.

His name was Sergeant First Class Nezamudin Nezami, but I knew him just as Nezam. His father, a Mujahideen fighter, was killed by the Soviets when Nezam was only four months old. He had no family, money, or hope — yet he became an Afghan Commando, one of the elite warriors trained by Green Berets to do 95% of the fighting in the war.

Green Berets, including me, who worked with Nezam, loved him like a brother. He volunteered for every mission, every day. He was family.

Despite numerous inquiries to the State Department, Congress, and Army SOF Command HQ, about his SIV status (Special Immigrant Visa), Kabul was falling and Nezam was in terrible trouble — and no one was coming to help him.

This was a guy who was shot through the face in 2010 while protecting U.S. Green Berets from a Taliban ambush. A friend, who despite being on the run from the Taliban, called me in my retirement every couple of months, just to check on my kids. And now we were just leaving him on the side of the road to be slaughtered. 

Over the next few weeks, I assembled a small team of volunteers, mostly veterans from across the country that we called Task Force Pineapple to guide Nezam and hundreds more to safety. 

No resources. No battlefield access. No time. But we had something that most didn’t. Relationships and trust. We used cell phones, knowledge of the terrain, and an encrypted chat room to guide at-risk commandos and their families at night. We navigated the suffocating crowd, through an open sewage canal, and into position to pass bona fides and tactically link up with known NATO service members operating near a four-foot hole in the airfield perimeter fence.

Pineapple wasn’t the only group. There were hundreds of ad hoc volunteer groups doing similar work. From breakfast tables to basements across the world. People like Jane, a Gold Star wife who lost her husband in Afghanistan; Will, a double amputee fighting to save the interpreter who saved his life; and dozens more collaborating with warriors like Aidan who were staring across razor wire at an endless sea of desperate faces.

We helped hundreds of allies, but thousands were left behind, and at great cost to this vulnerable veteran population, who had already given so much.

My buddy Steve, racked with PTS and a traumatic brain injury from an IED, pounded his bed, screaming into his pillow because his children were in the next room, as his former interpreter was detained at a Taliban checkpoint and was pleading over the phone: “Steve, they are beating my wife. My children are watching this for God’s sake. Should I fight them? Why is this happening?!”

Jay, A former Navy SEAL, received a text on Signal from his Afghan partner: “My daughter has been trampled, Sir. I know we are going to miss our chance to escape, but she is unconscious and barely breathing. It’s okay, my friend. Thank you for trying.”

This whole thing has been a gut-wrenching experience. I never imagined I would witness this kind of gross abandonment, followed by career-preserving silence of senior leaders, both military and civilian.

I believe we are on the front end of a national security crisis as 27 violent extremist groups are now operating on former NATO bases with Taliban top-cover. And we are about to experience a veteran mental health tsunami, as 73% of our Afghan War veterans say they feel betrayed by how the Afghanistan war ended.

Calls to the VA hotline have spiked 81% one year after the Afghanistan withdrawal. And the calls keep coming. My friend Brad was found dead a few months ago in a Mississippi hotel room. His wife Dana confirmed the Afghan abandonment re-activated all the demons he’d managed to put behind him and he just couldn’t find his way out of the darkness of that moral injury.

America is building a nasty reputation for multi-generational, systemic abandonment of our allies that we leave as smoldering human wreckage from the Montagnards of Vietnam to the Kurds of Syria.

Our veterans know something else that this committee might do well to consider: We might be done with Afghanistan, but it’s not done with us. The enemy has a vote. If we don’t set politics aside and pursue accountability and lessons learned to address this grievous moral injury on our military community; and right the wrongs inflicted on the most at-risk Afghan allies, this colossal foreign policy failure will follow us home and ultimately draw us right back into the graveyard of empires where it all started. 


Lieutenant Colonel (Retired) Scott Mann is a former U.S. Army Green Beret with tours all over the world including Colombia, Iraq, and multiple tours in Afghanistan. He is a warrior storyteller and the founder of Rooftop Leadership and the author of the instant New York Times Best-Seller, Operation Pineapple Express. He has since founded Operation Pineapple Express Relief, a 501c3 to help support the emergency needs of our Afghan allies such as safe passage out of Afghanistan, plus unforeseen resettlement needs.

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Daily Wire.

Already have an account?

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip
Download Daily Wire Plus

Don't miss anything

Download our App

Stay up-to-date on the latest
news, podcasts, and more.

Download on the app storeGet it on Google Play
The Daily Wire   >  Read   >  ‘Gross Abandonment’: Former Green Beret Tells Congress A High Price Was Paid For Chaotic Afghan Withdrawal