YouTube channel Jubilee’s latest “Surrounded” episode put Shark Tank’s Kevin O’Leary in a room with 20 Gen Z workers. The clashes went viral: O’Leary called one guest a whiner, and a software engineer asked why he should have to beg investors for money. Beneath the sparring lies a worldview that millions of young Americans share: the game is rigged, and the government should swoop in to fix it.
Over and over, participants framed their case in terms of effort. A security guard described working 80 hours a week while spending 50% of his pay on his landlord. The software engineer argued that Starbucks’ profits belong to the baristas because they “did the work,” and another guest cited the claim that productivity has far outpaced wages since 1979 as proof that the system is stealing from workers.
These are painful to watch. All the kids think they’re so smart, when it’s just complete nonsense.
— Brent Scher (@BrentScher) November 16, 2026
The instinct is understandable, but nearly every grievance in the room came back to an idea economists abandoned in the 1870s: the Labor Theory of Value, which holds that something is worth the effort put into it. Value is subjective. Digging a hole and filling it back in is hard work, but it’s worth nothing to anyone. An ER nurse’s hour is valuable because of what it does for the patient, not because of how tired she is afterward.
Pay works the same way because a wage signals how much value your work creates for others and how hard it is to find someone else to create it. O’Leary’s framing was often harsh, telling a security guard who has submitted hundreds of applications that he just wasn’t looking hard enough, but the underlying point holds true whether or not the messenger was glib. The way to earn more is to do something that other people value more, not to put in more hours doing something they value the same.
Kevin O’Leary calls a Gen Z worker a WHINER after he confronts him about how young people are struggling with LOW WAGES, student debt, unaffordable housing and the threat of AI replacing jobs, arguing that working hard no longer guarantees the same opportunities previous generations had 😳👀
“Every generation has had whiners like you”
— Killa 🌺 (@KillaKreww) November 15, 2026
Gen Z workers may have fundamentally misunderstood that hard work isn’t the same as value, but that misguided understanding rests on some legitimate claims that the deck feels stacked against them.
Housing is the clearest example of a legitimate grievance. In 1990, the median home cost 3.1 times the median income. Today it costs 4.9 times. Adjusted for income, homes are nearly twice as expensive for millennials as they were for Boomers at the same age. Gen Z is inheriting that market in a country short more than 4 million homes. When rent eats half your paycheck, it’s easy to conclude that the system is rigged and effort doesn’t pay. Disgruntled workers call for more government intervention, and that misses the point. Government built this wall of unaffordability, not “greedy capitalists.”
Even comedian John Mulaney seems to be following this, based on a recent skit.
John Mulaney hosts SNL and nukes Baby Boomers from orbit https://t.co/YIWoUFWjcC
— Stephen Kent (@StephenKentX) November 16, 2026
Scarcity drives up home prices and rents, and scarcity is a policy choice. The National Association of Home Builders estimates that regulation adds more than $130,000, about 26%, to the price of a new home. That cost has grown 40% since 2021, more than twice as fast as disposable income. And it doesn’t count the projects city councils kill because a few neighbors complained.
In June, RAND found that impact fees are a barrier to new housing in California and that simple reductions would unlock thousands of new homes. Add on single-family zoning restrictions, parking minimums, lot size requirements, open-ended reviews, and you get scarcity at scale.
That’s why the solutions floated in the room, from wealth caps to mandated profit sharing, miss the mark. They ask government to fix a shortage it created. Rent control chokes off new supply, and subsidizing demand bids up prices. The fix is less government, and it’s already working where it’s been tried.
Look at Austin, Texas. Between 2015 and 2024, the city grew its housing stock by 30%, three times the national average, simply by getting out of the way. It rezoned for apartments near jobs and transit, cut parking mandates, and made backyard units easier to build. Median rent fell from $1,546 in late 2021 to $1,296 in early 2026, even as the population boomed.
While often overly blunt in his delivery, O’Leary was describing an economy where effort aimed at something people value is rewarded and a paycheck stretches far enough to build a life.
Gen Z may want the government to hand down a prescribed version of the American Dream — but what it needs is less obstruction.
***
David Clement is the Policy Director at the Consumer Choice Center.

David Clement.png)
.png)

