A few weeks ago, I screwed a chicken kill cone into an oak tree in our backyard and prepared to kill Harry Potter. Not the wizard. Our rooster.
Harry Potter had become a menace, one who had decided that chasing my three young sons around the yard was his life’s calling, and after one too many encounters, I decided his days were numbered.
There was just one problem: I had absolutely no idea how to slaughter a chicken.
I come from generations of Irish farmers. These are people who have no issue raising animals, growing a garden, and putting dinner on the table — without consulting the internet. Yet here I was, a 30-year-old mother, attempting what my grandparents and father would have considered an ordinary Tuesday. So, naturally, I turned to YouTube.
Now, I didn’t love killing the chicken, but I wasn’t going to let an aggressive rooster terrorize my children. And if we were going to take an animal’s life, I thought it was important that we make good use of it. I had both my 6- and 4-year-olds help me pluck him. I told them they didn’t need to look at the headless part. It was gross, I explained, and they could just focus on the feathers.
My 6-year-old shrugged. “I’m not scared, Mom. It’s just a chicken, like from the grocery store.”
I couldn’t stop thinking about his response. The only difference was that this one hadn’t arrived cleaned, packaged, and conveniently missing all the parts we’d rather not think about.
We’ve become so removed from the production of our own food that something as ordinary as processing a chicken feels like a major undertaking. Yet at our nation’s founding, roughly 90% of Americans worked in agriculture. Today, farmers make up about 1% of the adult population. Within a few generations, a skill that was simply part of life has become a YouTube tutorial or an Instagram reel.
Yet many Americans are scrambling to get it back. When bird flu pushed egg prices to a record $6.23 a dozen in March 2025, Americans bought chickens. Suppliers reported selling chicks two to three times faster than usual, and backyard flocks now sit in nearly double the number of households they did in 2018, when the figure was 5.8 million.
The same impulse is behind the Make America Healthy Again movement. The Food and Drug Administration has announced plans to phase out synthetic food dyes by the end of 2026, and in 2025 legislators introduced roughly 75 dye-related bills across 37 states.
But I wonder whether we’ve gotten so focused on what’s in the food that we’ve forgotten to teach our children where it comes from.
We want pasture-raised eggs, grass-fed beef, and farm-to-table menus. Social media is full of women in linen dresses collecting eggs and arranging vegetables in perfectly curated wicker baskets. But what I’ve noticed is that there’s a significant gap between the homestead “aesthetic” we see online and the homesteads that actually exist. Sometimes chickens get sick, sometimes the garden you’ve spent a ton of money and time on produces nothing, sometimes the rooster you named after a children’s book character turns out to be a complete jerk.
And sometimes you have to kill him. That’s the part we don’t talk about nearly enough.
I’m not suggesting everyone start butchering poultry in the backyard. There’s a reason we have farmers and an agricultural system that feeds hundreds of millions of people, and I’m enormously grateful I can buy a chicken for a few dollars rather than spend an afternoon plucking one. But convenience has a way of erasing the work behind what we consume.
My husband and I wanted chickens not just for the eggs, but to teach our boys responsibility. Our oldest makes sure they have food and water whether he feels like doing chores or not. His reward is collecting fresh eggs, which is a pretty fun perk for a 6-year-old.
Harry Potter taught the harder lesson. I didn’t want my boys watching me slaughter him, and I don’t think children need to witness every unpleasant reality to understand it. But I also didn’t want to pretend that meat magically appears in plastic packaging. The rooster they’d helped feed was the same animal we were now preparing as dinner.
As a Catholic, I believe God entrusted creation to our care. Now, that doesn’t mean treating animals like people, or the other extreme, like disposable objects. It means taking responsibility for the world around us, including the animals we raise for food. That responsibility is sometimes messy, and we learn it by living in creation rather than just talking about saving it.
My sons probably won’t become farmers, but I hope they know how to grow something. I hope they aren’t afraid to get their hands dirty. And I hope they never take for granted the farmers, the animals, and the generosity of God behind every meal.
After the plucking, I still had to figure out how to gut the rooster, which required another round of YouTube and a humbling realization that I have a lot more to learn. But eventually I produced something that looked like the chickens I’ve bought at the grocery store.
While it was hardly a glamorous afternoon, somewhere between the feathers and the hot water, my boys learned something I wish more children could: Food doesn’t come from a store. It comes from the land, from animals, and from people willing to do the work.
As my oldest son said, he wasn’t “scared.” He wasn’t horrified. It was just a chicken, like from the grocery store.
***
Clare Ath is the co-founder and president of Vita et Terra, a conservative Catholic environmental nonprofit that champions care for creation.
This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

Clare Ath.png)
.png)

