Arguably one of the most tone-deaf responses to this year’s midterms is the finger-pointing at transgender messaging as the reason the GOP lost the election. The argument goes that voters don’t actually care about the issue, and GOP ads may have even backfired by riling up the Democratic base.
Meanwhile, Democrats veered away from radicalism, at least rhetorically, while blue state voters passed propositions protecting women’s spaces and children from mutilating procedures. This issue is far from unpopular. Republicans’ job moving forward is to hold Democrats accountable while supporting these ballot initiatives when necessary, because without that support, these measures will eventually become as obsolete as California’s Proposition 8.
The number of voters choosing a common-sense stand on transgender issues while voting for a Democrat is not insignificant. Initiative 638 hit the ballot in Washington state with a proposal to safeguard the fairness of girls’ sports by prohibiting biological males. Despite Democrats’ near-rout of Republicans on Election Day — winning eight of the state’s 10 House seats — the sports measure passed with a 13% majority.
Colorado, another blue state that only turned bluer on Election Day, passed two significant measures: Proposition 134, which requires K-12 and college athletes to participate on teams corresponding to their biology, and Proposition 135, which protects children from gender-transition surgeries. Both passed with at least a nearly 4-point lead, even as Democrats won the races for Senate and governor and flipped up to three House seats.
The trend continued in Arizona, where Democrats flipped two red seats blue and romped to a trifecta at the state level, all while passing a measure to protect girls’ sports and spaces in schools by a nearly 20% majority. In Nebraska, the same deal played out: a measure upholding biological reality in sports passed easily, while Democrats won back a House seat and overperformed throughout the state.
Beyond these state results, national exit polling reinforces the majority support for these measures, with 52% saying “transgender rights in society” have “gone too far.” Other studies have shown the same trend: Americans are tired of the LGBTQ fever. They don’t want their kids swallowed by the gender industrial complex, and they don’t want their daughters being forced to speak out after facing trauma, injury, and/or an unfair loss due to the invasion of their athletic and private spaces by males.
Even Democrats are starting to sound the retreat on their radical positions. This election cycle saw many prominent Democrat candidates more or less adopting Republican talking points on women’s sports and sex changes for minors, with some even airing ads to this effect. Given that the party has historically acted in lockstep with its LGBTQ activist base, this shift is a strong sign that these issues remain highly relevant.
Despite the overwhelming support for common sense transgender measures, Republicans like former Texas House speaker Dade Phelan and GOP consultant Matt Mackowiak have pointed the finger at transgender issue ads as a reason the GOP lost, despite the fact that they have been shown to move persuadable voters. In 2026, amid an unpopular ongoing war in Iran, persuadable voters are few and far between.
Nearly a decade ago, no one understood the dangers of the Democrat trans agenda. Now, after much work, the political momentum is finally on the side of sanity. States like Washington and Colorado teach a clear lesson. But those gains could easily be lost if the Left is once again allowed to dominate the debate.
These ballot measures will mean nothing if Republican lawmakers stop messaging and give up the fight. The short life of California’s Proposition 8 in 2008 supporting traditional marriage should be a lesson: Republicans can’t leave the job before it’s done. This means enforcing these state ballot initiatives where possible and holding Democrats accountable where necessary, putting their feet to the fire if they stray from what the majority of voters asked for on Election Day and what some of them promised to uphold. Already, Democrats in Seattle are working to block the measure protecting girls. This cannot be allowed.
As the country heads into 2028 and the Republican Party begins seriously working to win back the support of the American people, the evidence presented by these ballot measures and the shifting Democrat messaging should not be ignored. A conservative agenda on transgender issues was not the problem in 2026. Rather, candidates lacked a strong economic message to pair with their positions on trans issues, and ballots across the country split. It only behooves Republicans to stay on offense on the culture war heading into 2028.
***
Anna Poff is a media associate at American Principles Project.

Anna Poff.png)
.png)

