Amanda Seyfried Wants To Make Divorce ‘Boring.’ It Never Will Be.
Photo by Lexie Moreland/WWD via Getty Images

Upstream

Amanda Seyfried Wants To Make Divorce ‘Boring.’ It Never Will Be.

If we celebrate every divorce, then what is the point of marriage?

Madeline Fry Schultz
Listen
Listen
5 min

Divorce is a lot of things: messy, expensive, emotionally taxing, confusing for children. One thing it’s not is boring. But that’s what celebrities tell themselves so they can sleep better at night.

Famous people think their divorces are different, better, than other people’s. That’s the self-soothing narrative that gave us Gwyneth Paltrow and Chris Martin’s “conscious uncoupling” and Frankie Muniz and Paige Price somehow pairing their divorce announcement with a video of them dancing to “Check Yes, Juliet” with their poor, unsuspecting child.

The latest justification for tearing apart a family comes from actress Amanda Seyfried, who first gushed about her divorce from actor Thomas Sadoski in September. “We have been separated for a while, and it’s proven to be the right move for us and our family unit. We’ve got each other forever — and it’s GOOD,” they said in a statement.

Last week, the lady continued to protest too much, methinks. She reposted a quote from a divorce consultant calling the act just another neutral life event.

“The most radical thing we can do is make divorce boring,” it read. “Make it normal. Make it accessible. Because the system thrives on confusion and stigma, on making you believe you’re the first one to ever walk this road. But when divorce becomes just another life transition — like a wedding, like a graduation — the patriarchy loses one of its most effective weapons.”

That darn patriarchy trying to keep you married!

Most people agree that divorce is sometimes the right decision, especially in extreme cases, cases that would make staying friends afterward totally out of the question. Divorce expert Olivia Howell, whose post Seyfried shared, sometimes speaks about divorce brought on by domestic abuse, which is a far cry from the “boring” decision to separate from a man who forgets to close the bathroom door when he’s on the toilet.

“There is something almost holy about a woman starting over with her children,” Howell says in one post. Domestic abuse victims deserve all of the resources and support they can get, but couples who have simply “grown apart” and are now looking for the next new thing should not receive our applause. If we celebrate every divorce, then what is the point of marriage?

Media outlets are eating up Seyfried’s reframing exactly as she surely hoped. “Amanda Seyfried’s Surprisingly ‘Refreshing’ Take On Her And Thomas Sadoski’s Split Is Inspiring People To Recall Their Own ‘Boring’ Divorce Experiences,” a BuzzFeed headline gushed. People magazine went with “Amanda Seyfried Posts Sweet Photo with Estranged Husband Thomas Sadoski Alongside Quote About Normalizing Divorce.”

Howell even wrote a follow-up article for Business Insider, saying that she got a divorce when her children were 4 and 7. “I want them to understand that adults can change their minds and their lives,” she wrote. “Sometimes putting yourself first is a radical decision.” What a terrifying lesson for kids, who don’t care about their parents’ inner peace and just want both mommy and daddy to hug them in the morning.

Amid acknowledgments that divorce can cause great pain, Howell offers what has been conventional wisdom at least since “Eat, Pray, Love” and really since the advent of no-fault divorce. “People grow and change throughout their lives,” she writes. “Sometimes we grow together, and sometimes we grow in different directions.”

For those of us who still believe that marriage vows mean something, however, there is no growing in “different directions.” There is no “graduating” to a different, more elevated and self-actualized phase. There’s merely a broken vow and, possibly, children whose lives will never be the same.

Contrary to the media headlines and self-help books, not everything needs to be destigmatized. Sky-high divorce rate aside, the norm should be for married couples to stay together, not to break apart on a whim. When an otherwise happy couple suddenly calls it quits, it’s fair for us to ask why — and for friends of the couple to see if there’s any path to reconciliation.

Divorce can be the right decision. It can also be incredibly selfish. One thing it cannot be is boring.

***

This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip