Selfish Reasons To Say ‘No’ To Gentle Parenting
Getty Images

Upstream

Selfish Reasons To Say ‘No’ To Gentle Parenting

You know what we don’t talk about enough? The ways gentle parenting harms today’s parents.

Listen
Listen
6 min

Gentle parenting is bad for kids, for so many reasons. Emphasizing young children’s feelings in lieu of shaping their behaviors is ineffective and counterproductive. It renders them less capable than their authoritatively parented peers and puts them in a position to miss out on opportunities from which better-behaved kids can benefit. Moreover, in the longer run, having been gentle parented inculcates fragility, solipsism, and illogic that leave tweens, teens, and young adults vulnerable to various mental health issues.

We talk all the time about these ways that gentle parenting negatively affects today’s kids. But you know what we don’t talk about enough? The ways that gentle parenting negatively affects today’s parents. Or, even more specifically, the ways that eschewing gentle parenting in favor of parental authority makes the experience of parenting better. Or, depending on whom you talk to, makes parenthood doable at all.

In fact, I’ll go so far as to say that if people realized what functional parenthood could and does look like absent today’s gentle parenting norms, we might have to worry a lot less about population decline. So, without further ado, the top five selfish reasons to say “no” to gentle parenting.

You can take your children places you want to go. Public spaces really have gotten less child-friendly. That’s absolutely in part because our values as a society are not as child-centered as they should be. But, as I have written, it’s also because parents have become too child-centered. They’re allowing overindulged children to ruin restaurants, parks, and shows for everyone else. As a result of this devolved norm, responsible parenthood (at least once the kids hit toddler age and are no longer sleepy and portable) can seem like voluntary house arrest. But it doesn’t have to be like that. Sure, crawlers have needs that are not great for coffee shops or hikes. But once toddlers are walking, you can start training them for obedience in low-stakes places like parks and kid-friendly restaurants. By age 2-and-a-half to 3, you should be able to take them pretty much anywhere (within reason). By 4, they should be no more likely to throw a tantrum in Target than you are.

You can have adult conversations with your spouse around your kids. It’s no fun going to adult-oriented spaces with your kids — or, honestly, being at home with them either — if you can never string three sentences together without interruption. If you require a date night in order to get a word alone with your spouse while the kids are awake, that takes a toll on your marriage and your mental health. Well-trained kids who have not been gentle parented understand “be quiet, play upstairs,” and so on. That’s what gives you the crucial ability to connect with your husband or wife in the course of normal family life, no babysitter required. (Obviously date nights are still great, and you should have them if you can; but a date night should feel like a special opportunity to go out, not a rare hostage release.) 

You can get work done when your children are home. Along the same lines as being able to talk with your spouse, being able to talk with your colleagues or finish work projects at home is a huge perk of being a less-than-gentle parent. Flexible work arrangements function best when you can also flex some amount of child care. Obviously kids under 3-and-a-half or so require some amount of hands-on care, but being harder on your kids’ behavior will yield you 5-year-olds who are self-sufficient enough to entertain themselves, more or less, while you work. In addition to the financial benefits of not needing child care for every moment of professional productivity, the familial benefits of being around your kids while working are worth a lot. “Low quality” time together is important, but it can only work when your kids are well-behaved. 

You can trust your kids. Kids who’ve been gentle parented often reach their tween years stunted. The helicopter parenting that has an unprecedented quarter of American 11-year-olds not allowed to leave their own yards is probably largely warranted, given how a lot of these 11-year-olds have (not) been formed. If kids grow up believing that their own emotions constitute the greater part of reality, and nothing intervenes to challenge that misperception, they become soft and gullible adolescents. They also become unreliable narrators because the line between what’s real and what’s in their heads has been fuzzy for them since toddlerhood and remains so. When your kids have less independence as they grow, so do you. Moreover, when your growing kids remain less than cogent, you worry more. Inculcating high standards early on, by contrast, sets a foundation for future dependability. 

You can handle a(nother) baby. I don’t think that I know any gentle parents with four or more kids, and I know very few with three. Gentle parenting makes parenthood simultaneously so difficult and so unrewarding that people are afraid to take it on or don’t think they have the bandwidth to take it on again. But it doesn’t have to be like this! Obviously, children require work and attention. But being a parent can actually be not only purposeful, but fun, if you put in the work early on to make your children people you actually want to be around. If you do that, you’ll likely want another baby. And maybe even another. And, best of all, you’ll be able to enjoy them.

***

Elizabeth Grace Matthew writes about books, education, and culture, including on Substack.

This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip