In the last week, these systems broke down: Microsoft Outlook, the FAA, Workday, Apple, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, United Airlines, JPMorgan, the National Weather Service, and the National Security Agency.
We don’t trust our institutions already. Our government totally blew it on COVID. Our journalist class blew it on Black Lives Matter and Joe Biden’s health. The expert class blew it on nearly everything. And tech bros are simultaneously orgying and also waxing philosophic about how “AI will destroy the entire universe, now here’s my IPO.”
So what do we expect people to feel when the things stop working?
Panic is out there. I get it; I feel it too. Nothing annoys me or freaks me out more than when tech stops working. It can ruin your day; it can ruin your business day. It can destroy your business.
But we don’t have enough information yet. And in the absence of information, speculation tends to run rampant.
The biggest problem is that people in positions of power aren’t good at communicating with us or telling us what the hell is going on. Without clarity, panic will spread.
You can feel it. People are upset. They’re worried that there will be runs on banks or that tomorrow all the systems will go down. People feel something is coming; everything’s going to break all at once, the zombie apocalypse and all the rest.
I get why people are feeling this way — and we know why it spreads.
What matters is fixing the problems in front of us so life can be normal, which is what most Americans are still desperately looking for.
The Wall Street Journal stated:
The anxiety is understandable. Behind the scenes, there have been relentless AI-driven cyberattacks, an avalanche of software patches amid Bugmageddon, sleepless nights for IT staffers and so much cybersecurity work that incident responders are turning away business. While outages are nothing new, AI has created a pressure cooker that makes it difficult to discern cybersecurity threats from the ceaseless updates that amount to their remedy.
Everything’s moving incredibly fast, and when you update a system, you may be ingesting a bug.
Just two months ago, technology executives were warning the public of an AI apocalypse and Dario Amodei — whose company, Anthropic, is expected to make its initial public offering later this week — warned that rogue AI systems could take down the entire internet.
This is part of the problem: You have spokespeople for tech who are out there, saying, “Your life could be destroyed by my system. Now I’m going to IPO. Would you like some stock?”
It hasn’t helped calm nerves that cybersecurity pundits dubbed this past month “Black October,” as investigators responded to an unprecedented number of intrusions, many of which were fueled by a new AI hacking tool called Artex.
Hackers used to have to write code, and it took a while. They would discover a vulnerability. There’d be a lag between the release of a new system and the discovery of a bug.
But now, because AI is so fast, it can deconstruct the code incredibly quickly. So tools like Artex can find bugs quickly and exploit them.
This year, there have been an unprecedented number of system upgrades in North America. Security experts say that it’s fair to blame that phenomenon on AI.
The benefit is also the drawback, because AI is improving things so fast and systems are trying to update to stay competitive. That also leaves vulnerabilities that the same fast AI system can exploit.
In April, Anthropic released Mythos — a product tuned for cybersecurity that has proved to be uncannily good at finding software bugs.
That made sense because cybersecurity is about finding the bugs and fixing them. Thus, theoretically, you could use cybersecurity software to find bugs and exploit them.
OpenAI has followed with models of its own. As a result, this year has been unlike any other when it comes to the number of bugs down and patches issued. Last month, Microsoft released patches fixing about 1,400 security flaws in its products during its monthly software update. It was a record number of patches. A year earlier, the tally was about 170.
You could read that as a bad thing: you need more patches, but you could also read it as a good thing: you can spot bugs and fix them faster.
Flaws in another product called HP came to light in October, and were considered so serious that many organizations shut down their websites rather than risk being hacked. In recent weeks, other serious bugs were uncovered in the Linux operating system and the Java programming language — both of which are ubiquitous among American corporations.
Yes, there are cyber-attack risks, and yes, there are bugs; all of that exists. Many companies are downloading software at the same time. That is most of what we are seeing right now. Because they are doing these software updates, bugs come with them. Many of those bugs can be exploited or hacked or are themselves problematic in implementation.
It’s important to note that, from the timeline of the companies affected by the outages, how quickly they were fixed.
Twenty years ago, the most common tech failure was accidentally clicking a malware ad on your computer, which would infect it with a bug. It would destroy your entire system, and you would have to get a new computer. It could take weeks to debug your computer.
Perhaps your antivirus software wasn’t good enough. Sometimes the antivirus software that you downloaded — if you did it for free — actually contained the bug.
Chase, Bank of America, and Wells Fargo had some outages for online banking services. JP Morgan cited a software rollout issue. All of them were fixed within hours.
Some of this came from natural updates that were being downloaded to systems; they were buggy, and then they had to be debugged. Some of this came from systems being exploited.
And some of it we just don’t know.
All of that is disquieting because the pace of technology is disquieting. With the adoption of new technology at scale, you end up finding many of the bugs in the new technology at scale, not in a restricted fashion, but affecting lots and lots and lots of people.
A lot of bugs are going to crop up, and a lot of bugs are also going to be fixed.
But that doesn’t mean it’s not scary and disquieting.
The best information suggests that we are not experiencing a mass hack attack against all major systems in the United States, or AI being used to take down all our banks.
Many of our systems continue to work. But if you can’t message this issue, if you are not fully transparent, if it feels like the information is dispensed in dribs and drabs, the American people are going to start to speculate and get freaked out, and they’re going to pattern-spot between all of the failures.
There may be no relation whatsoever between the failure of Microsoft Outlook and the FAA failing, but when it feels like everything is breaking, that feels like a problem of competence.

Ben Shapiro
.png)
.png)

