Natalee Holloway. You’ve heard the name, but have you heard the story? The full story of the teenager from Alabama who vanished, creating a worldwide search that lasted decades. What happened to Natalee Holloway? I’m Lynden Blake, and you’re listening to That’s So Criminal.

Daily Wire

Lynden Blake

That's So Criminal

Natalee Holloway Should Be 40

Let's go back to Plymouth, Massachusetts, for another hearing in the Lindsay Clancy case. Based on prior hearings... we are sure this one will go smoothly. Why is Kevin Reddington stuck on the holdout juror who went with his convictions? Does the prosecution even want to try this case again? In today's That's So Criminal, Lynden Blake breaks down the November 2, 2026, court session.

This episode is audio only.

Lindsay Clancy Trial Pt 9: The Retrial Runaround

A woman goes missing the same day her and her ex-fiancé’s episode of The People’s Court airs on national television. Is it a coincidence or a crime? 15 years later, Michelle Parker’s families are getting answers as her ex-fiancé is now charged with second-degree murder. What new evidence led to his arrest, and where is Michelle Parker?

People's Court Murder Pt. 1: Ex-Fiance Caught

More royal family drama surrounding Meghan Markle. If true, you can call her father royally disgusting after being accused of one of the most heinous crimes. Has Meghan reached out to her estranged pops as the investigation pops off? And how long have authorities in the UK known about these alleged images?

Meghan Markle's Father Under Investigation

Usually NFL fans get their Sundays started with the Sunday NFL Countdown but in Virginia, one man decided to go with an NFL Sunday lockdown. You’re not going to believe this story of a woman who found herself a prisoner in her own home.

Duct Tape & Touchdowns

Christa Pike back in a prison cell after two failed executions. What went wrong? Does Christa Pike have rights? Will she be executed again? Or will this go to trial... and become a landmark case? There are plenty of scenarios...

Christa Pike Botched Execution Pt 2: What's Next?

Is there a serial killer on the loose near a Michigan college town? Why police are now labeling the five killings over the last year along the Lansing River Trail as potentially connected? The public may not like it, but Lynden Blake explains what takes so long to connect these types of crimes, plus who is most at risk?

This episode is audio only.

Michigan Serial Killer Pt 1: Is It Happening Again?

The Happy Face killer had many names, one being Happy Face, two being Keith Hunter Jefferson, and the third being Just Dad. We talked to the serial killer's daughter, Melissa Moore. Does she still talk to her dad after his killing spree? And why she moved back to the scene of the crime? Are there signs that Melissa may have missed?

"Killer in the Family" by Melissa Moore is available here: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Killer-in-the-Family/Melissa-G-Moore/9781637749586

Happy Face Killer's Daughter

Let's go back to 2018, when a Minnesota grandmother spent five weeks as one of the most wanted fugitives in the country. She was accused of two murders across multiple states. Lois Reese was a wife, a mother of three, a grandmother of five, and for years a well liked daycare owner in her small hometown. Investigators say a gambling addiction that cost her half $1 million in a casino led her to commit murder, first at home and then again over a thousand miles away against a practical stranger.

This episode is audio only.

Killer Grandma Sparks Nation-Wide Manhunt

Jaime Dugan rose to fame competing on the popular reality show "Survivor," but now she's making headlines for a much darker scenario. The influencer mom is being accused by her ex-husband, who also competed on "Survivor" for running away with their 16-year-old son. Lynden Blake dives into their troubled past on That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

"Survivor" Mom Wanted By FBI: Where Is Harper Huffman?

Christa Pike, The First Woman Set To Be Executed In Tennessee In 200 Years, Survives Not One But Two Lethal Injections. Is She Made Of Steel? Or Is This Part Of Some Kinda Plan? We Dive Into The Cruel Crime That Put Her On Death Row Nearly Three Decades Ago.

This episode is audio only.

Christa Pike Botched Execution Explained: Is She Still Alive?

Crybaby Caleb Flynn is guilty of murdering his wife. It took the jury less time that it took him to write his AI song for his mistress to decide the former American Idol contestant’s faith. What Ashley’s family wants the world to take away from this tragedy? Does Caleb even have remorse?

This episode is audio only.

Caleb Flynn Trial Pt. 3: America's Most Hated Husband

Lindsay Clancy's back in court this time with a new demeanor and her defense team back with a new story. Kevin Reddington is trying to defend his client, but is he taking down the judicial system in the meantime? Or is he the savior this story needs?

This episode is audio only.

Lindsay Clancy Trial Pt 8: Kevin Reddington Flips The Script

The alleged mistress was forced to read her text messages aloud in court as the Caleb Flyn trial hit the one-week mark. Now, the damning words Alleigha Botner allegedly said about Ashley Flynn are coming to light. Could those messages lead to charges in Ashley’s murder?

Caleb Flynn Trial Pt. 2: Diabolical Day In Court

A former American Idol contestant and music pastor in Ohio is on trial for the murder of his wife. This after a years-long affair with another member of the church’s worship band. Did the mistress know Caleb Flynn was going to kill his wife Ashley? You're listening to That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

Caleb Flynn Trial Pt. 1: Mistress Tells All

The ex-husband of Lindsay Clancy has been seemingly laying low, but now the father of the three murdered children who died at the hands of Lindsay Clancy sits down with 60 minutes. What questions weren’t asked? And is Patrick Clancy's new wife pregnant? We talk about all sides of this highly-anticipated interview in That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

Lindsay Clancy Trial Pt 7: Patrick Clancy Goes On 60 Minutes

The Eliot Spitzer scandal is back in the headlines because of a reality TV show involving some pretty influential people. It's a politics culture crossover that is still talked about nearly 20 years later. Lynden Blake dives into Ashley Earle's past now that it's a present day storyline on the Netflix show "Earle Meets World."

This episode is audio only.

Eliot Spitzer Scandal Gets New Life

Lois Gibson is the world record holder for most identifications by a forensic artist. Today, I'll be speaking with her about her near death experience that led to her pursuing this line of work, as well as her involvement in the Nancy Guthrie case.

America's Forensic Artist

A Lindsay Clancy obsessed woman is at the center of a murder investigation involving her two-year-old?

Lynden Blake details the Corie Walsh case. Do we have a copy cat on our hands? In this episode of That’s So Criminal we explore how Clancy’s trial has impacted society moving forward.

This episode is audio only.

Copy Cat Killer

A mistrial declared in the Lindsay Clancy case. What happens next for the mother who admitting to killing her children? Did the judge mess this trial up from the start? We talk next steps on That’s So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

Menu