The alleged mistress was forced to read her text messages aloud in court as the Caleb Flyn trial hit the one-week mark. Now, the damning words Alleigha Botner allegedly said about Ashley Flynn are coming to light. Could those messages lead to charges in Ashley’s murder?

Daily Wire

That's So Criminal

Diabolical Day In Court

A former American Idol contestant and music pastor in Ohio is on trial for the murder of his wife. This after a years-long affair with another member of the church’s worship band. Did the mistress know Caleb Flynn was going to kill his wife Ashley? You're listening to That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

Alleged Mistress Tells All

The ex-husband of Lindsay Clancy has been seemingly laying low, but now the father of the three murdered children who died at the hands of Lindsay Clancy sits down with 60 minutes. What questions weren’t asked? And is Patrick Clancy's new wife pregnant? We talk about all sides of this highly-anticipated interview in That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

60 Minutes With Patrick Clancy

The Eliot Spitzer scandal is back in the headlines because of a reality TV show involving some pretty influential people. It's a politics culture crossover that is still talked about nearly 20 years later. Lynden Blake dives into Ashley Earle's past now that it's a present day storyline on the Netflix show "Earle Meets World."

This episode is audio only.

Eliot Spitzer Scandal Gets New Life

Lois Gibson is the world record holder for most identifications by a forensic artist. Today, I'll be speaking with her about her near death experience that led to her pursuing this line of work, as well as her involvement in the Nancy Guthrie case.

America's Forensic Artist

A Lindsay Clancy obsessed woman is at the center of a murder investigation involving her two-year-old?

Lynden Blake details the Corie Walsh case. Do we have a copy cat on our hands? In this episode of That’s So Criminal we explore how Clancy’s trial has impacted society moving forward.

This episode is audio only.

Copy Cat Killer

A mistrial declared in the Lindsay Clancy case. What happens next for the mother who admitting to killing her children? Did the judge mess this trial up from the start? We talk next steps on That’s So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

One Angry Man

A dead end in deliberations in the Lindsay Clancy trial. What happens next for a jury in deadlock? Is a mistrial the likely option? Lynden Blake explores it with prosecutor David Gelman on That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

Jury Deadlocked

The jury is in deliberation deciding the fate of Lindsay Clancy.

Lynden Blake will tell you how the prosecution painted a picture to the jury of the final moments of the three children's lives.

Was it calculated? Was it a mental break?

Plus Kevin Reddington tells us how he thinks he did during his closing arguments.

This episode is audio only.

Lindsay Clancy Verdict Watch

The Lindsay Clancy trial is set for closing arguments. This is the finale of the trial. What will be the prosecution’s final push to prove Clancy was criminally responsible for killing her three children? And the one hole the defense couldn’t close in their case. Plus, a shocking decision by the judge.

This episode is audio only.

The Hole In The Defense

An OnlyFans model went from riches to rags after being accused of killing her boyfriend. Behind those private jets and vacations was a pretty tumultuous relationship between Courtney Clenney and Christian Toby Obumseli. We're going to dive into what Courtney Clenney claims led up to that fatal stabbing in Miami.

Plus, will this former Instagram star returned to social media soon? I'm Lynden Blake and you're listening to That's So Criminal.

This episode is audio only.

OnlyFans Murder

Thursday was suppose to be the long day in the courtroom for the Lindsay Clancy murder trial ... it was the shortest. Are conspiracy theories shutting down the operation? Why is the case coming to a halt when there are reportedly more witnesses? Plus, the bombshell testimony from the chaplain who was with Lindsay after the murders of her three children.

This episode is audio only.

Shakeup In Courtroom

The Lindsay Clancy case is in a pivotal moment as the defense takes center stage in week four. The prosecution wants Clancy convicted of first degree murder for killing her three young by strangling them with exercise bands. What is the defense's strategy to prove Clancy was in a state of psychosis?

This episode is audio only.

The Defense Psychosis Diagnosis

Today Lynden Blake dives into the disappearance and death of Nolan Wells, a Mississippi college student whose final hours on Horn Island are unusually puzzling. From a disputed distress call to a mysterious altercation on the island, the timeline keeps splintering, and none of the evidence seems to add up.

This episode is audio only.

What Happened to Nolan Wells?

A Los Angeles judge just ruled that musician D4vd will stand trial for the murder of 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. In today’s episode Lynden Blake traces D4vd's suspicious online purchase history, the newly revealed text messages between him and Celeste, and what prosecutors say is still to come as this case heads to trial.

This episode is audio only.

The Evidence Against D4VD

Six months after Nancy Guthrie vanished from her Tucson home, the full text of two ransom notes is finally public, and the details don't match. Lynden Blake breaks down the shift in tone between the notes, a mention of a smart watch investigators hadn't confirmed yet, and why Savannah Guthrie still believes the messages are legitimate.

This episode is audio only.

Finding Nancy Guthrie: Reading Between the Lines

Days before her death, TikTok influencer Sara Duffey posted a viral video calling her husband out as a pedophile. She didn’t know it would be one of the last things she ever did. Lynden Blake traces the jurisdiction dispute over Shawn Duffey's crimes, the protective order Sara filed against him before her death, and how the people of this small Oklahoma community are making peace with the loss of their friend.

This episode is audio only.

TikTok Murder Suicide

Lance Twiggs may have immunity for what he's said, but that doesn't put every question about him to rest. Lynden Blake talks with former prosecutor David Gelman to unpack exactly what that immunity means, whether an accessory charge could still be on the table, and how well Twiggs' testimony might survive cross-examination if Tyler Robinson's case goes to trial.

This episode is audio only.

Can Twiggs be Charged? David Gelman Weighs In

Deputies in rural Ohio serving a routine warrant found something no one expected: sixteen children who’d been living in a twelve-by-twelve-foot room for four years.

In this episode, Lynden Blake breaks down the discovery of the Ohio “House of Horrors" and the four adults now facing felony charges.

This episode is audio only.

Ohio House of Horrors

Thirty years ago, a nine-year-old girl rode her pink bike into a parking lot. Eight minutes later, she was gone. Her kidnapping was never solved, but it led to something that's since saved over 1,300 children: the AMBER Alert. This week, Lynden Blake traces Amber Hagerman's story, from a Winn-Dixie parking lot in Texas to the system that now bears her name.

This episode is audio only.

Menu