I Witnessed Oxford’s Anti-Fascist Fascists Try To Silence Controversial Speaker
Credit: Leon Neal/Getty Images

DW Opinion

I Witnessed Oxford’s Anti-Fascist Fascists Try To Silence Controversial Speaker

Masked mob gives Oxford a failing grade on free speech — and basic decency.

Harriet Dolby
Listen
Listen
5 min

Last night, Oxford saw a resounding fight against free speech. One thousand people, some students, but many very clearly not, came to protest against Nathan Cofnas speaking at Oriel, one of Oxford’s 700-year-old colleges. Violence ensued.

It was unsurprising that Nathan Cofnas received such a hostile welcome, being the American academic who first raised plagiarism accusations against Jason Arday (the individual lauded as Cambridge’s youngest black professor, who lied about his visiting professorships, a cancer battle, and his marathon running endeavors). Arday’s death is of course a tragedy, but Cofnas is not his murderer, like many of these protestors sought to suggest.

Cofnas is undoubtedly a symbol of all that the extreme-left hate: he is Jewish, a “race-realist,” and a proponent of free speech.

Oxford had been lined with posters by “Stand Up to Racism” (a left-wing organization that frequently tries to deplatform right-wing individuals), publicizing the demonstration in their classic Warholian-agitprop style. Last week, I heard a fellow student I know say she was helping organize the protests. I knew it would be big.

It started off peacefully, with marquees and placards ready from the Socialist Workers Party (waving the obligatory transgender and Palestinian flags), Unison healthcare workers (a local trade union branch), and, of course, Stand Up To Racism. The omnicause was at its full force.

As soon as it turned 5 p.m., a mob appeared; various communist and anarchist groups marched in flags and balaclavas to conceal their identity. While we waited by the entrance point as the security guards futilely faffed with the non-alphabetized invitation list, it was this group that shoved us out of the way, pinned us against the wall, and started shouting, declaring their support for antifa. Fortunately, after darting around the corner, we were half-heartedly allowed in, at this point physically shaking. For context, I was with three other petite female friends; the fact that we were physically harassed by these protestors begged the question: if this is how they treat women in public, how do they treat them in private?

Oxford’s been here before, of course; Tommy Robinson visited the Oxford Union last term with a half-empty chamber as an audience because of the impenetrable human chain. It was at that demonstration, again with Stand Up to Racism, as well as other organizations, that I saw many of my friends who were innocently trying to get into the talk spat on, punched, and kicked to the ground.

The police were unhelpful, opting to stand on the other side of the road watching innocent people get hurt, protestors breaking and entering the building and scaling walls to try and disrupt the event. Two-tier policing at its finest.

Once inside, we could breathe a sigh of relief — only to be subjected to the “vigil” for Arday within the college. No official protests were supposed to occur inside, but if this was a vigil, it was a rather interesting interpretation. There were the obligatory candles and the hot drinks stand in the corner in case their fingers went a little numb. But the booing, heckling, and “Nathan Cofnas is a C*nt” chants didn’t seem like the respectful, mournful tone a vigil should embody.

After a comedic bump into a priest attending the talk in the gender-neutral toilets, who looked slightly perplexed at the sanitary products on offer, we headed up the stairs to the library.

So, against the backdrop of empty bookshelves, book wallpaper, and two striking columns, Cofnas stood to give his speech. He proved a man completely unfazed, if not bemused, by people outside the window calling him a “nazi” despite his Jewish heritage. It quickly became apparent these protestors struggled to rhyme Cofnas with pseudoscience, so their futile, albeit loud, shouts meant Cofnas needed a microphone to speak.

Only 20-30 people made it inside, and now came the new challenge: getting out. We were in a big escape-room challenge; we went to each exit to find it barricaded by face-masked individuals shouting at us. Delightful. Thankfully, the police did intervene somewhat and enabled some room for us to run out of the building, but I was stalked by several keffiyeh-wearing individuals who shouted “shame on you” at me as I attempted to ditch them by weaving through Oxford’s streets. The police, by the way, simply watched this happen.

The violence and intimidation used were terrifying; whilst I do not necessarily agree with Cofnas, I do firmly believe that we should have the right to free speech, especially at university, a place where we should hear from people who have different points of view. Clearly, those who were outside “fighting fascism,” whilst physically and verbally threatening young women, were really fighting to destroy the very concept of free speech.

***

Harriet Dolby is a student at the University of Oxford, the ex-President of the Oxford University Conservative Association and a Parliamentary Researcher in the House of Lords. 

Create a free account to join the conversation!

Already have an account?

Log in

Got a tip worth investigating?

Your information could be the missing piece to an important story. Submit your tip today and make a difference.

Submit Tip